I can actually tell you that Windows NT source code is everything but "a pile of crap". I can't tell for exchange or IISS, but I would be very surprised that it's crap.
Security is extremely difficult. It's even more difficult for a consumer product.
Even OpenBSD had remote exploits in the default install.
Also I happen to know more than one (grey?) hat who makes/sells 0day of Microsoft products. Microsoft opened Pandora's Box pissing off security researchers a few years back, there are many wounds to heal.
And on your OpenBSD bashing, they have a very good security record. Sure, Theo had a short temper, but they always worked very hard on security and most of his rants were related to drivers (and IMHO, he was almost always right.)
Edit: very minor clarifications.
I simply do not believe your unattributed story about security advice at Microsoft "falling on deaf ears". For the past several years, a large subset of "famous security experts" have been falling over themselves to present at Microsoft's private internal Blue Hat conference.
Incidentally, before you decide to call me a Microsoft apologist, you might be interested to know that I worked on the original OpenBSD security audit (back when the company I worked at, SNI, started the audit), and for several years wrote the OpenBSD security advisories. I also spent 4 years working at Arbor Networks, then largest commercial OpenBSD security product company in the world.
Also, if you're wondering why people are downmodding you, start by considering that 'shin_lao didn't bash OpenBSD.
> Microsoft is in fact doing a better job with software security
> than any other large company in the industry
[IMHO] Google does a much better job and Microsoft still needs to rewrite a lot of their code base to be safe. And their bad usability record also counts against them, as stated on my original response.Again, sure, Microsoft beats Apple/Sun/Oracle/Cisco. I agree 100% with you there. (As stated before.)
I'm sorry you feel like this is getting ridiculous, but what I think is happening is that you've once again bumped into someone on Hacker News that isn't simply going to concede the point to the person with the greater zeal for the issue. I get it. You like OpenBSD. You prefer open source. You prefer Google to Microsoft. This is all understandable. Unfortunately, your ideology doesn't change the facts on the ground.
> what I think is happening is that you've once again bumped
> into someone on Hacker News that isn't simply going to concede
> the point to the person with the greater zeal for the issue.
I hold a very slightly different view from yours (e.g. I think Microsoft is doing a lot about security and other giants should take note, as in the original reply.)It is sad people look for absolute right and wrong. Why can't we have both different views and not necessarily be wrong? In particular on a difference in opinion.
> I get it. You like OpenBSD. You prefer open source.
I like some things about OpenBSD, in particular their code auditing, but of course it's far from perfect. If I remember well, more than once Theo argued against something and later on it became a major feature of the project.About projects, I consider myself a bit of a sad agnostic lately. In particular I haven't used OpenBSD in a long time.
> You prefer open source.
Yes. But I happen to use closed source everyday and don't have problem with that. I use iWork to create PDFs and slides, sometimes. Hah, I'm even OK with crappy proprietary software (iTues+iPod), nothing I can't handle.Apple, and in particular OS X and Safari, in the security side are a disgrace. But I can live with it (e.g. use Chrome with JS/Flash disabled by default, use TrueCrypt and other encryption software as much as possible, and be very careful where I plug my notebook and what I authorize in it.)
> Unfortunately, your ideology doesn't change the facts on the ground.
What ideology? You just did a (bad) guess at my stance. And even if you were right, it was just ad-hominem.Counter example: I hate Google's anti-privacy hypocrisy. Same for their server-side services, and [also for] removing power from the users. Microsoft always empowered users with tools, it's their business model. I liked them a lot [back then] when things changed from server-side borderline authoritarian systems [to empowered Wintel PCs]. And now the world is coming back to [centralized systems], sadly.
-- Please read my statement on OpenBSD again, the keyword is "even" which implies I view the security of this os rather highly.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority
It's a shame HN users end up shooting down any contrarian opinion. In particular a piece of opinion like this one, there isn't an absolute right stance.
And don't get me wrong, I've been vocal about Microsoft working harder on security than, say, Apple/Sun/Oracle/Cisco. I just don't think they are "in fact doing a better job with software security than any other large company in the industry." That's a long shot. Google does their homework, to name one.
Virtually every product they ship has been tested by iSEC Partners, Leviathan, IOActive, or (in some rare cases) Matasano. For the most part, Microsoft does not get the B-teams from these firms. If you care to check those company names out, just Google [<company> black hat].
Virtually every single developer at Microsoft has been trained in secure software development, and has formal incentives tied in some way to software security.
Virtually every Microsoft product has a documented threat model, almost certainly constructed by a third-party assessor.
Most Microsoft products have fuzzers (the ones that don't are hard to fuzz). In many cases those fuzzers were written by people like Mike Eddington.
Microsoft has delayed major product releases --- like operating systems --- to re-audit after people found bugs that shouldn't have made it to the final stages of QA.
I'm somewhat familiar with Google's practices. I invite you to counter my evidence of Microsoft's superiority with specific examples of how Google "does their homework". Google does a fine job, so you should have no problem.
(b) In neither IIS 6 nor IIS 7 have any of those published advisories granted attackers kernel access of any sort. In fact: find me the last IIS vulnerability that did give up the kernel. I bet you can't.
Also; authority was the wrong word to use - experience is a better one. I'm generally inclined to trust his experience (especially as it partly matches my own observation too)
You're citation was not really proving a counter argument (I did downvote - but only after it was +3)
Tom would seem to count as an original/authoritative/primary source :)
(when the counter citation is completely off the point I think that says something important)
Sure, the "pile of crap" was a bit juvenile. But that doesn't invalidate my point.