News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Optane Memory – A bridge between DRAM and storage by ChuckMcM on Monday March 27, 2017 @02:58PM (#13970621)
The 'win' in theory for this stuff is that it is much faster than SSDs at low queue depths and it is significantly more write tolerant.

An interesting interesting system design might be a 2GB main memory with a 32GB swap partition on this device. That would be interesting because in idle mode it uses less power than an equivalent amount of DDR memory. So you could potentially build a laptop with good performance on larger memory tasks but longer standby battery life. It would also be interesting paired with an equivalent amount of DRAM where it mirrors main memory so you could have 'instant' off and 'instant' on type booting and shutdown.

At larger pool sizes this becomes interesting as a non-volatile index for NoSQL and other databases. Intel's claim has been in the past that its density can exceed SSDs by a healthy margin.Not seeing that in these products but time will tell.

I've been watching them struggle to productize this tech for about 2 years now[1]. Now to see if they can get it to live up to the hype.

[1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/07/intel-and-micron-unv...

Re:Optane Memory – A bridge between DRAM and storage by mtgx on Monday March 27, 2017 @04:27PM (#13971447)
> Intel's claim has been in the past that its density can exceed SSDs by a healthy margin

Seems doubtful they would reach that goal until SSDs hit some kind of hard plateau (kind of like HDDs did).

Toshiba plans to make a 100TB SSD over the next couple of years, and I believe Samsung has already announced a 16TB SSD. I doubt 3D Xpoint can catch-up with those in the given time frame.

Re:Optane Memory – A bridge between DRAM and storage by wtallis on Monday March 27, 2017 @08:38PM (#13973014)
NAND flash memory already hit the wall for horizontal shrinks, and some products plowed past that limit and into the regime where day to day use was invoking the second level error correction methods to compensate for data degradation.

3D NAND turned the clock back on horizontal scaling and cell sizes by several years, and now the only scaling opportunity is to increase layer count. That's not going so well. Samsung started with 24 layers but didn't ship retail products until they hit 32 layers. Their 48 layers was about a year late and caused several products to be scrapped entirely. Toshiba's on their third generation 3D NAND and it's only just starting to show up in the market. SK Hynix is doing worse than Toshiba. Intel and Micron started off reasonably well with their 32-layer and are working on ramping up 64-layer.

By the end of this year, all four manufacturers should be shipping 64-layer (72 for SK Hynix) 3D NAND in volume, or else it's time to admit that 3D NAND just doesn't scale up as well as we hoped it would.

There's some reason to believe 3D XPoint memory might be able to avoid the worst vertical scaling problems that are holding back 3D NAND flash. Each pair of 3D XPoint layers can be pretty much isolated from the rest of the layers except at the edges, whereas 3D NAND is building columns of bits that run through all 64+ layers and have aspect ratios that are quite high.

Re:Optane Memory – A bridge between DRAM and storage by markvdb on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:17AM (#13975175)
I can see some potential in things like RERAM to scale beyond 3D NAND and bridge the SSD/RAM gap. I like the technological elegance of non-filamentary RERAM [2] in particular.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resistive_random-access_memory [2] http://www.4dsmemory.com