Re:Patent Troll: Bloomberg calls it what it is
by loewenskind on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @04:39AM
(#1397449)
>Consider this, if Micron had decided to enforce their patents across the industry would that be bad? They technically wouldn't be a patent troll since they actually are making products. Now they would almost certainly be countersued for patents in their competitors portfolios, whereas this company doesn't work in the industry so has no fear of defensive patents.
But this is precisely why it's wrong. Micron made patents for things they made. Instead of using them to stop others from using their inventions they chose to use the patents to let them violate other company patents. This was their choice. If they had chosen to enforce those patents, maybe no other company would have violated them. Now someone who wasn't involved gets to flip the table on all those companies who played along.
Imagine being a co-founder in a start up where your partner said "I'll never screw you out of anything" and then promptly hires someone else to do it. Would that be cut-and-dry enough for you?
Consider this, if Micron had decided to enforce their patents across the industry would that be bad? They technically wouldn't be a patent troll since they actually are making products. Now they would almost certainly be countersued for patents in their competitors portfolios, whereas this company doesn't work in the industry so has no fear of defensive patents.
I could certainly see it funny if their competitors made similar agreements with this company or some similar one and all got sued for patents that had originally been in the hands of competitors. That seems to me to be the equilibrium if what Micron has just done becomes standard industry practice for generating liquidity from R&D.
The only thing I can think of that might improve the situation would be to apply something like adverse possession to the patent system. That is to say if someone is openly violating some patent that you have, then you have a limited amount of time to seek compensation.
That would fix a lot of the problem with patent trolls: namely that the industry has adopted some innovation wide-scale and suddenly someone shows up with a patent on it from 15 years ago.
I'm sure there would be negative consequences too, since every change has those, but I'm not thinking of them at the moment.