Re:Logic Production Systems: A new mixed logic/imperative pr...
by PaulHoule on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:53AM
(#13968730)
+1 for the rules-driven compiler, it's one of those things that could put programming language innovation into many more hands.
Re:Logic Production Systems: A new mixed logic/imperative pr...
by trapperkeeper79 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:44AM
(#13976960)
Getting RETE right isn't trivial. I tried looking into the fundamentals a few months ago, and was very unsatisfied - it felt like people explaining it knew parts of it but not the whole thing. I guess it is good that we have some open source implementations that can be reverse engineered by someone motivated enough.
I likewise find it sad that the idea has died so much that we continue to build square wheels that were made obsolete by rule engines. I remember a futile attempt at Amazon to get a team to scrap their system in favor of a RETE based rule engine. Theirs was a poorly performing and fragile homemade "rule engine" that compiled xml rules into if/else statements, which after tens of thousands of rules had slowed to a snails pace. Somehow the magic of O(1) escaped them, and they practically required me to reimplement their system from scratch in order to convince them. So I let it go.
I had never considered the possibility of killing callback hell with a rules engine but I can definitely see it now. I personally have toyed with building a compiler that eschews the pipeline architecture with a rules engine where both analyses and optimizations are implemented as rules. I definitely think there is a world of possibilities out there, but maybe we'll need another AI winter before people consider them again.