I like it. I can generally tell from a tl;dr summary whether the original material was interesting and/or whether it has been fairly summarized.
No, you can tell whether the person making the comment was lazy or not, it won't tell you anything about the original material unless you read that too to verify the summary was correct.
And it definitely isn't a rule that they are.
Edit: This was about the previous title to this submission. The submitter fixed it.