News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments (2013) by stinos on Monday March 27, 2017 @03:33AM (#13965803)
Is that really what authority means? I always thought it was along the lines of 'famous guy X says Y so Y must be true'. While a dictionary on the other hand is something which I'd really consider authorative i.e. correct when it's about the meaning of words. So a dictionary's reason of existence, it's whole prupose is explaining the meaning of a word, you could say it states the actual facts. Wehereas some famous guy saying something doesn't make it a fact automatically just because he's famous.
Re:An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments (2013) by c3534l on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:19AM (#13968410)
That's what makes it a valid appeal to authority, rather than an invalid one.
Re:An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments (2013) by __ddd__ on Monday March 27, 2017 @05:30PM (#13971948)
It just means the authority is relevant. If you pull out Merriam Webster in an argument about the meaning of the term "racism", you are appealing to authority, which is a logical fallacy. Appealing to authority is a logical shortcut, like any other fallacy, and in a way can be thought of as memoization. Every single logical fallacy has an efficient purpose, but departs from pure logic.