News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Adams Theory of Content Value by btilly on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @01:51PM (#1395634)
His analysis is too simplistic.

There is no question that the value of each individual piece of content for each user will drop. However there is also no question that we get more utility out of the content we have, and therefore there is no question that the value of all of the content we have is greater.

The important questions are what fraction of that utility gets captured as income by various providers along the way (a smaller slice of a bigger pie can still be more), and how much an individual provider can capture.

Data from the music industry indicates that musicians who share their music freely make more money in the long run from increased concert sales, and memorabilia sales. (The Grateful Dead are an extreme example.) Data from http://www.baen.com/library/ shows that putting books online increases sales. So we have two examples where more free content translates into more money.

However for now it appears that the search engines, particularly Google, are in the best position to capture value out of the utility of content. But Google recognizes that it is in trouble without content creators and is actively trying to help. Here is hoping that they succeed.

Re:The Adams Theory of Content Value by jacobolus on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @02:33PM (#1395758)
Putting books online increases sales by giving extra exposure to those books which are online, compared to books which are not online. Assuming that it would still boost sales if all books were online is a textbook example of the fallacy of composition.