Plus, after reading articles like http://www.mcsweeneys.net/links/panoramaexcerpts/Ali.html regarding how mortgage servicers and banks deal with foreclosure, I'm disinclined to believe that they are ever acting in good faith.
You do realize that it's perfectly reasonable to be disgusted with the mortgage originators, the Wall Street financiers, the CDO managers, the CDO manager's clueless investors, and the feckless homeowners who got into bed with them, right?
And yes, I think the homeowners there pretty awful. But the banks didn't determine that they were awful before they acted in bad faith; they acted in bad faith from the get-go, for everyone, whether or not their actions merited such treatment.
And from where I sit, it seems like the banks and servicers are the ones who completely failed to do any due diligence and then blamed the economy when their unsustainable loans proved, well, unsustainable. The average person is functionally innumerate. They are going to make poor decisions regarding quantitative matters, especially quantitative matters couched in ways that are deliberately obfuscated. This is not true of the average bank. I expect better from them.
Your other two grafs don't actually rebut anything I said. Yes. Banks bad. Very bad! Also: require Thomas to sit on hold to wait to talk to someone in Bangalore about mortgage. Ridiculous fees, too! Bad! Unfortunately: still not OK to defraud them. Contracts with bad evil banks? Still valid.
In general, I do not expect main stream publications to be able to edit articles regarding economics. Journalists and editors are astonishingly ignorant of basic economics, to say nothing of statistics or law. There's a reason that economics professor Dean Baker keeps an entire blog devoted to correcting the idiocies and distortions found in traditional reporting (see http://www.cepr.net/index.php/beat-the-press/ ); it is the same reason that economics professor Brad Delong regularly lambastes major newspapers on his blog by chanting "why, oh why can't we have a better press corps?" (see http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/better_press_corps/ ). So the fact that this article didn't appear in the Washington Post (where I've read "fact-checked" articles which presumed that inflation does not exist) doesn't really trouble me. It is written by an attorney and officers of the court are generally subject to sanction if they misrepresent cases.
I like McSweeney's probably almost as much as you do
Um, I don't read McSweeny's; I read this article because it was linked from an economics/policy blog I respect.
Unfortunately: still not OK to defraud them.
I don't believe the behavior in question falls under fraud statutes.
This is surprising: generally we expect corporations to act in their best interest taking full advantage of their rights under the law, even if doing so violates the spirit of the law. How odd that we apply such different standards to individuals.
But you should read McSweeney's. It often pretty excellent.
And McSweeny's certainly does have editorial standards. Libel is still a crime, which both McSweeny's and the attorney who wrote the article are very much aware of.
I think the only thing I could really wish for here is a system that captures some of the funds that these people are spending on trucks or business schemes and, in exchange for some long-term plan to keep them in their houses, get them to start paying back into their commitments. It is certainly true that the financial system shoulders some of the blame for this untenable situation.
A pox on all their houses, then.
There have been several proposals that would accomplish this, including Dean Baker's Own to Rent ( http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/2007/08/19/own_to_rent_... ); I believe all of these proposals have been vociferously opposed by the finance industry. One reason is that it would probably force banks to mark down the values of their assets to something more realistic. I believe these proposals would be very popular though with the general public....
Squatters living in a home owned by a bank prevent squatters from moving in?
Again, there are degrees of maintenance. They won't be incentivized to put in a new deck or repaint the whole house, but a lot of the value destruction associated with foreclosure has to do with simpler things: animals taking residence, water damage, thieves stealing the wiring/plumbing and ruining the walls in the process, etc.
If you said "people who squat in homes they used to own may perform maintenance and keep out a worse breed of squatters than themselves", I would have had no objection.