Re:Sea Ice Extent Sinks to Record Lows at Both Poles
by JoeAltmaier on Friday March 24, 2017 @02:17PM
(#13950981)
But isn't it the case that CO2 levels could not be seen as a direct indicator of ice levels in say the last 35 Million years? The ice-free times correspond to high CO2; the icebound times to low CO2. But in between there's considerable difference, and no simple correleation. One could be driven to think, something besides CO2 is (also) involved.
Re:Sea Ice Extent Sinks to Record Lows at Both Poles
by nickjarboe on Friday March 24, 2017 @07:56PM
(#13953221)
In recent geologic time CO2 levels seem to mostly be influenced by temperature instead of increasing CO2 levels causing temperature rise like today (there does not seem to be animals in past all of a sudden excavating and burning gigatons of carbon annually). Over million year timescales the biggest cause in the change in Earth's temperature is Milankovitch cycles[1] which is short hand for changes in the shape Earth's orbit and changes in the position of the Earth's spin axis. These changes interact to produce various climate conditions. The biggest factor is that sometimes these cycles cause the northern hemisphere to have very cold winters and other times mild winters. When the winters are very cold, continental glaciers can form on North America and Eurasia. They reflect more sunlight than land and the Earth gets colder. This is an ice age. Eventually the orbital and spin axis parameters change (over tens of thousands of years) and, with warmer winters in the northern hemisphere, the ice sheets begin to melt. With this positive feedback loop, the ice age ends quickly, the Earth gets warmer, and the Earth enters what is called an inter-glacial (we are in one now).
This is, of course, a very simplified explanation. As one goes back hundreds of millions to billions of years, other large scale changes like plate tectonics, atmospheric composition/mass, sun brightness, continental weathering, etc. will cause the average surface temperature to vary considerably.
Re:Sea Ice Extent Sinks to Record Lows at Both Poles
by mikeash on Friday March 24, 2017 @03:11PM
(#13951417)
I don't know enough about it to know whether it is as you say, but nobody denies that climate feedback loops are extremely complicated and there's rarely a direct relationship between any two numbers.
CO2 levels have been this high, and much higher, in the distant past. But the climate has also varied enormously in the distant past as well. Roughly 55 million years ago, the planet had nearly no ice. A bit over two billion years ago, it's believed that the planet was almost entirely covered in ice.
So no, it's not really a reasonable issue. CO2 levels have varied a great deal, as has the climate. Nothing in the Earth's climate past suggests that the current dramatic rise in CO2 levels wouldn't also result in dramatic changes to the climate.