Re:Dell’s 32-inch 8K UP3218K Display Now for Sale
by rleigh on Friday March 24, 2017 @03:03PM
(#13951345)
It's going to be more than twice--Nyquist-Shannon is for 1D; 2D images would have a lower resolution on the diagonals, so you'd want a minimum of twice the frequency on the diagonals.
In an ideal world, we would also be using hexagonal grids rather than square, which gives a resolution increase for the same area and a given pixel size, and also reduces off-axis aliasing.
Re:Dell’s 32-inch 8K UP3218K Display Now for Sale
by microcolonel on Friday March 24, 2017 @07:33PM
(#13953111)
Very astute, thank you for bringing this to my attention. So it'd be about 2 and 58/70 times the maximum frequency, assuming two-dimensional sampling.
As for hexagonal grids, there are a number of complications introduced by that, especially when it comes to using general algorithms based on regular 2D euclidean space.
Re:Dell’s 32-inch 8K UP3218K Display Now for Sale
by rleigh on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:18AM
(#13955258)
With a sampling rate of 2 on the diagonal, you'd have a rate of 2.828 on the axes, with a square grid (2 * sqrt(2)). Unless I'm missing something.
Agreed about the complications of the hexagonal grid. We make implicit assumptions everywhere. Though I'm not sure they are insurmountable for some purposes; with graphics APIs like OpenGL, texture coordinates and samplers could be using a hexagonal grid relatively transparently. That would allow use of hexagonal displays even if the texture data is square.
Re:Dell’s 32-inch 8K UP3218K Display Now for Sale
by acchow on Sunday March 26, 2017 @05:35PM
(#13963446)
The eye clearly has frequency limitations
No...the eye doesn't work that way. It is not a machine. It is organic and analog. It doesn't have some frequency limit. In any case, you're abusing the Shannon-Nyquist theorem. It absolutely does not imply that if some device is sampling at x hz then you can sample at 2x hz and produce a sufficient reproduction for the 1x hz sample. This is a common misconception.
The eye clearly has frequency limitations, so we just need to find the sampling strategy which accurately codes all perceptible frequencies.