News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by leereeves on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:34PM (#13944962)
What's Bloomberg's agenda here?

An article exactly like this one, graphically describing bloody car accidents from last week, could make the case that driving comes with a heavy price.

Or an article detailing the aftermath of failed surgeries paid for by the ACA: "universal health care comes with a heavy price".

Terrifying anecdotes are provocative, but unenlightening.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by function_seven on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:40PM (#13944994)
The article notes that safety precautions are routinely ignored. It also cites statistics in addition to the anecdotes. The agenda is to show that cheap manufacturing is maybe not worth the societal cost due to an injured workforce. We're supposed to be better than that.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by leereeves on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:49PM (#13945058)
The article also mentions (briefly) that things are improving:

> [OSHA] cited one year, 2010, when workers in Alabama parts plants had a 50 percent higher rate of illness and injury than the U.S. auto parts industry as a whole. That gap has narrowed, but the incidence of traumatic injuries in Alabama’s auto parts plants remains 9 percent higher than in Michigan’s and 8 percent higher than in Ohio’s.

Down from 50% higher to 9% higher.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by function_seven on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:49PM (#13945666)
You’re comparing different stats. The article should have been clearer, but here’s what they’re saying:

In 2010, AL parts plants had 50% higher rate of illness and injury than the national rate. That gap has narrowed since.

The incidence of traumatic injuries (a different category) in AL is still 9% higher than Michigan’s.

Also:

> In 2015 the chances of losing a finger or limb in an Alabama parts factory was double the amputation risk nationally for the industry, 65 percent higher than in Michigan and 33 percent above the rate in Ohio.

(Emphasis mine).

This article could do a much better job laying out the numbers, that’s for damn sure.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by allengeorge on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:40PM (#13944998)
I mean, there are stats in the article - specifically some that claim that the rate of injuries is substantially higher in the south than in Ohio/Michigan for example.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by leereeves on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:47PM (#13945048)
I mentioned Ohio/Michigan in my reply to another comment; here, I'd also like to point out that the stats aren't discussed impartially. For example:

> Alabama has been trying on the nickname “New Detroit.” Its burgeoning auto parts industry employs 26,000 workers, who last year earned $1.3 billion in wages

An average of $50,000 per year. Assuming that suspiciously round number is accurate, those are good wages in Alabama. Yet the author writes in the next paragraph: "Pay is low".

Is that simply because the author lives in New York and can't imagine a place where $50,000/year buys a good life?

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by abiox on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:05PM (#13945488)
averages aren't all that interesting given how skewed salaries tend to be. i agree that (in general) 50k isn't so bad in alabama.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by ky3 on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:46PM (#13945395)
The hidden agenda is promoting more laws and regulations. It's like the lawyer who insists to you that "The more court cases we file, the more justice there is in the world."

Lots of unsexy but well-paying jobs exist in regulation compliance in the USA. In fact it's a huge industry that has its share of tech startups with below average risks of coming up empty.

Sure beats being treated like a robot.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by abiox on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:55PM (#13945444)
is there a laws and regulations lobby?
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by ky3 on Thursday March 23, 2017 @09:35PM (#13945860)
Why lobby when such pieces designed to prick the public's moral indignation work so much better?

The cognoscenti recognize that lobbying is but one of multiple levers they could pull.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by rayiner on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:52PM (#13945077)
What agenda do you think a magazine owned by a billionaire targeted at Wall Street professionals has?
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by intopieces on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:50PM (#13945067)
What sort of enlightenment were you expecting that you did not find?

That is to say, what is your agenda?

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by leereeves on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:54PM (#13945087)
I can see how this story would play to Bloomberg's audience of wealthy professionals and would like to offer a different perspective.

Having worked in that field, coming from a family that's worked in the field, I know it can be dangerous work. At least, the occasional carnage makes for a more graphic story than the health consequences of sitting at a desk for 40 years.

That doesn't mean the jobs aren't appreciated, even enjoyed, or that blue collar workers (not Bloomberg's audience) would rather not have those jobs.

Also, I'm genuinely curious why Bloomberg has taken up this story. Is it simply an attempt to hurt Trump (who has made restoring American manufacturing a big part of his platform)?

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by intopieces on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:26PM (#13945283)
>Also, I'm genuinely curious why Bloomberg has taken up this story.

To provide a counter to the idea that "bringing back manufacturing" will be a panacea to that which ails the middle class. I think the article is transparent in its agenda.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by leereeves on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:29PM (#13945309)
Perhaps. There are people on the left whose goal is to make jobs unappealing.

"Jobs Americans won't do" so corporations can hire illegal immigrants and pay them pennies, or ship the jobs overseas and pay workers there pennies.

There's profit in that, I suppose. If so, is the agenda of this article, as you see it, to send those jobs to Asia or Mexico, where labor is cheap and OSHA has no authority?

Or perhaps laying the groundwork for Democrats to reach out to blue collar workers (many of whom turned to Trump in the 2016 election) with a push for worker safety?

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by graycat on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:17PM (#13945547)
For your

> will be a panacea to that which ails the middle class.

IIRC, Trump's campaign statement was "Jobs, Jobs, Jobs." Each time I heard him say that, I wondered, what kind of jobs, for how much money?

All I could think of was that OHSA, unions, various labor laws and inspections, and, then, likely most important of all, lawyers suing companies that have injured workers, would largely determine what kinds of jobs and for how much.

On the "how much" part, broadly we will have to continue to use the old forces of supply and demand: Or, with enough new manufacturing jobs, there will be a worker shortage. Then there will be more robots and better trained and paid workers to run the robots.

From the figure that the US has 90+ million people who could work not working, I suspect that the US is now essentially digging itself out of a big, black hole that it never should have gotten into in the first place.

IMHO, nearly all of Trump's campaign statements are simplistic in the extreme (I make this as something easy to observe and relevant but without a value judgment except that maybe such simplicity can be effective political speech making). But, maybe he is correct about manufacturing: Maybe to dig out of the hole the US needs to have a lot of the 90+ million working in factories. I would hope for better than that.

That factory work chews up people is a 100+ years old story. Maybe with enough in robots, good employers, etc. factory work can be made humane. Maybe the situation is better at, say, Boeing or Lockheed.

To me, that factories result in lost fingers, limbs, and worse is such an old story that there is little or no excuse for such things now. Lawyers that have laws suits that specify $1 million per finger should get the safety switches installed, the inspections done, the oil leaks fixed, etc.

IIRC, there are cases where the CEOs are saying that there are big shortages of well qualified, e.g., trained, workers. Of course, maybe the CEOs just want the taxpayers to pay for the training. Whatever, if training is needed, then it stands to be the case that the workers will be more highly valued by the CEOs.

We don't want bad situations. Maybe if nearly all of us are smarter from our educations, jobs, political participation, etc., we can do better.

For Bloomberg, both the person and apparently the publication, apparently they don't much like Trump. Mike Bloomberg has given $100+ million to medical research and education at Johns Hopkins University so is a good guy in at least some respects! Maybe he was on balance a good mayor of NYC. Of course, in NYC he was for (A) rules to reduce salt in restaurant food, (B) rules to forbid selling really large sugar sweetened soft drinks, and (C) putting wind turbines on the tops of the buildings in NYC. Gee, Mike, all those wind turbines -- would look like some hideous scene from a Gothic Batman movie! Maybe Mike just wanted the wind turbines only on the tops of Trump's buildings?

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by walshemj on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:04PM (#13945149)
And the average auto worker probably thinks well its not like a "snake" in a steel rolling mill or a marsh gas explosion in a deep mine.

A snake is where a red hot slab of steal comes off the rollers and flails around the factory floor.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by malandrew on Thursday March 23, 2017 @09:51PM (#13945927)
Is this what you're talking about: http://imgur.com/7rP7q5r.gifv
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by cft on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:52PM (#13945075)
Their agenda is to unionize workers in Japanese and Korean auto plants in the US. The reason American car brands are not competitive with Japanese and Korean US-made cars is that the US-brands owned plants are unionized while Asians are not.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by chris11 on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:03PM (#13945142)
Do you have any research to back that up? How much could someone save on a car if American car makers had Asian carmakers labor costs? I think American car manufacturers have bigger problems with their products.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by vinay427 on Friday March 24, 2017 @02:30AM (#13947096)
I think they recognized that (finally), which is why they're offering more of their European or other international models in the US.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by dilemma on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:22PM (#13945262)
American car brands are not competitive because they are poorly managed.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by Benjammer on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:44PM (#13945031)
>What's Bloomberg's agenda here?

FUD

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by whyenot on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:55PM (#13945094)
>FUD

Could you elaborate on that a little? You are responding to an article containing hundreds of words and the best you can do is three letters? Why is it in Bloomberg's interest to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt? Where is the article spreading uncertainty and doubt? I'm not seeing anything.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by leereeves on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:58PM (#13945104)
It's obvious that the article is spreading fear. It's full of terrifying stories.

Why is that in Bloomberg's interest? Great question. That's what I'm wondering.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by ecopoesis on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:21PM (#13945257)
FUD means fear, uncertainty, doubt.

I don't think the point of the article was any of those: like most media I'm sure Bloomberg's interest was ad impressions. Which they got from me, and will probably continue to get from me because they publish interesting articles like this that inform of things I didn't know.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by alphabettsy on Thursday March 23, 2017 @10:32PM (#13946137)
Some of the other commenters have spent more time dissecting the writer and publication than the content of the story. If the story contains false or objectionable content I could see the reason for bringing this up, otherwise I personally can't really understand the point.

The article mentions plenty of things to indicate possible motives including wages, unionization, and safety regulations. Besides that these seem to be real stories that I honestly would've probably never heard about otherwise. Naively I didn't think most of these jobs were very dangerous, especially after reading stories about Chrysler workers caught drinking and smoking weed at the plants. After reading those stories I assumed these jobs were maybe demanding, but how hard could they be if they can be done while under the influence..? This story brought new perspective for me. Where I see new information, others are only seeing ulterior motive and maybe there's a bit of both.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by leereeves on Thursday March 23, 2017 @07:27PM (#13945292)
I don't think Bloomberg founded a news agency for the profit from ad impressions.

News organizations have agendas, particularly when they share the name of a nationally known politician.

Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by ecopoesis on Thursday March 23, 2017 @08:14PM (#13945530)
When Bloomberg was founded, Michael Bloomberg was a politician yet. He was a man trying to make money.
Re:The US South’s manufacturing renaissance comes with a hea... by malandrew on Thursday March 23, 2017 @10:04PM (#13945986)
Honestly, I don't think it necessarily has to be something in Bloomberg's original interest as a business-focused news outlet.

In the past few years, individuals with a strong SJW mindset have infiltrated so many media outlets resulting in the promotion SJW values with near religious fervor.

Look at other stories from this same author: https://www.bloomberg.com/authors/APuwLdDPlj8/peter-waldman

According to his LinkedIn, his focus is on long-form investigative journalism for Bloomberg living in San Francisco.

With this in mind, the question remains, why is it in Bloomberg's interest to have a writer like Peter Waldman?

I suspect the reason is just to remain competitive for clicks with other news sources like HuffPo, Vox, etc. These days, Bloomberg isn't as focused on their original market as the WSJ or the FT.