I have a collaborate writing forum for young teens which don't have credit cards.
Maybe you think my forum shouldn't exist because it depends on ads, but as someone who grew up on a similar writing forum and developed my love for writing at a young age, I'd disagree.
The answer to your question is simple: it doesn't matter. Replace "content creator" with a more general "service provider" and my point remains exactly the same. There is no good reason why we need to defend ads, specifically, as a business model, other than "it's already in place". And while "being in place" is a rather strong force, more and more people are using ad blockers. I would consider that a pretty clear indicator that we need a better system.
There's one last thing I would like to clarify about my argument: no matter what systems we have or lack, the question is always who cares for something enough to pay for all of part of it. Ads try to take that question away, but they don't -- they merely make it seem like they do. But even if we didn't have the ads, there are always ways to shift the burden of payment away from the totality of the consumers.
For example, the service could be sustained through a donation drive. Wikipedia comes to mind right away, but so does the PTSA of the public school my son goes to. Another source of funding might be the service provider: there are people out there so passionate about what they do, that they'll pay the costs out of their own pockets. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying everyone should depend on altruism, but it's also an option that doesn't get brought up enough.
There is such a thing as artificially inflated demand, which can be a problem, but I don't think it's likely that all advertising falls in that bucket.
I understand the desire to make money flow towards the content creators. I understand the desire for free content. I understand that the ads seem to "solve" both of those problems. I just don't understand why people think it's better to keep investing our time and energy into trying to save ads instead of looking for alternative solutions.
So why ads?
But yeah, personally I'd prefer a different system. I really like the idea of micropayments, but I don't know how that would look exactly.
The users have heard that too often. We're all out of trust to give.
If every web user blocked all ads, content creators couldn't get any revenue and would stop making content.
If every web user blocked all ads, content creators wouldn't be able to get any revenue from ads. There are other ways of getting revenue.
What's the alternative?
There's what @libeclipse said in his comment: if you somehow make this tech work in popular browsers, then there are people who might be willing to try it and maybe it becomes the accepted solution.
Other than that? Paid content. Yes, that makes it harder for content creators to get money and harder for content consumers to get free content. So what?
Are we really so convinced that everyone who creates anything deserves to be paid for it? Do we really need so much free content? More specifically, are we all so convinced of these two things that we're okay with giving up our rights on how to render web content on our own computers? 'Cause that's what it boils down to in the end.