Re:IPad: $1 Billion Later, What Do You Think of It Now?
by ahoyhere on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @09:14AM
(#1394949)
Guess it depends on what you're going for! If you want a digital sketch specifically, then it seems worth it to try with a stylus and a doodling or sketching program.
But Omnigraffle is not for drawing, it's for formalizing. Just like an outlining tool is not for thinking, it's for expressing what you've already clarified in your head.
Computers require you to formalize -- make decisions, order, and choose form -- totally prematurely.
I find pen & paper to be the best thinking tool there is because it's completely free-form.
If you want the next best thing to paper, try that stylus hack and a doodling program, not a tool like Omnigraffle.
Napkins + Pen are about 10x faster for quick sketching, and about 15-20x more accurate for fine-grained details.
The iPad is many things, but a replacement for my pen and notebook it is not.
I'm in a lab right now, and a quick network sketch of the components took me 30 seconds. Using omnigraffle, (God, I pray I somehow manage to get my $50 out of that App), it took me about 5 minutes.
Of course, the difference is I now have a rich-vector drawing that I can email, modify, update, and _always_ have with me.
I would be very, very interested in hearing about other people's experiences using their iPad as a: o Sketch Book o Technical Diagramming Tool o Not Taking Devices.
Particularly your success and techniques. :-)