Re:PostgreSQL vs SQL Server installation Faceoff
by viraptor on Monday May 31, 2010 @06:11PM
(#1393636)
Sure - it's a WTF. But if you want to show that X is better than Y to professionals, you don't say "Y sucks omgwtfbbq". We're (mostly) capable of reading lists of dependencies and a summary like "dependencies of X are: ... and weight ...MB, while dependencies of Y are: ... and weight ...MB, but we don't see the reason for dependencies: ...". Pointing fingers and laughing usually makes people aggressive, instead of showing a valid point. It's not dumb - there's a reason why it's installed as a dependency, even though it has bad sides too.
Latch wrote "The goal is to show Windows folk" - there are ways to show things without ridiculing the opposition. It's HN, not some other service, so let's try to keep the level high.
Re:PostgreSQL vs SQL Server installation Faceoff
by rbanffy on Monday May 31, 2010 @07:59PM
(#1393858)
I completely agree that this is not - and should not be - the place for childish behaviour. It's however, hard to show MS SQL's installed side by side with Debian's APT and not look like you are trying to ridicule SQL Server. The WTF's are mostly noise I really haven't noticed until a second pass through them.
And "Windows folk" may very well not be appropriate terminology. This is a hacker place. There are Windows users, Windows enthusiasts (who tend to severly mod me down when I get carried away) and some Windows developers (the kind that develops Windows, not for Windows) and we should really try to keep everything civilized.
A humorous jab here and there won't hurt, however.
Re:PostgreSQL vs SQL Server installation Faceoff
by matwood on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @04:11PM
(#1396006)
The thing that you're missing is that MSSQl is much more than just a database server. Now, I agree that if all you're trying to do is install the bare minimum RDBMS then IIS shouldn't be required. .Net though is always going to be required because you can write extended stored procedures in c# and have full access to the .Net object library (very cool btw).
IIS is going to be required when installing parts of MSSQL like SSRS or MSAS since they can interact with client tools and users through IIS.
The less you install on the database box, the less stuff you have to upgrade, the less exposure to security critical bugs you have and the less downtime for upgrading you will get.
Mandating .NET framework and IIS is just dumb.