News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research Debt by chestervonwinch on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @04:18PM (#13934466)
> quoting a reviewer: "This paper lacks math."

Why didn't you place the additional detail in an appendix, so as to not detract from the main points?

Re:Research Debt by beambot on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @06:25PM (#13935580)
Most journals have very strict page limits.

(Also: The mathematical underpinnings are related to radar systems, whereas the application is in robotics. The amount of background information to bring a roboticist up to speed would've consumed entire papers or books -- some of which were previously published by myself & other coauthors.)

Re:Research Debt by ylem on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @11:49PM (#13937267)
In my field (physics) I find that an increasing number of journals allow supplemental materials. You provide the main story in the text, but can add a lot in the supplemental materials. For example, suppose we have discovered a new material with some exciting properties. There is a fair amount of characterization that we do just to convince ourselves that we made what we think we made. A lot of this can go into the supplemental materials for those that want to make sure that we have done the standard sanity checks. A long time ago, you would write a short letter, then a longer report. That fell away, but I am really a fan of supplemental materials when used correctly.