That's a nice way to get your child ostracised by the group. Once a teen leaves elementary not having a smartphone (specifically Android or IOS) is the kiss of death in this modern age.
What an absurd amount of power and choice to cede to companies and people who do not care about you.
But pragmatically speaking, what alternative do you have with a twelve year starting their secondary education? Do you want your child to be the only one in class without a smartphone? Kids in middle/high school use apps (WhatsApp etc.) to stay in touch — not just for gossip and chat, but also for coordination of class assignments and social gatherings — and you want to exclude your child from this?
It would be more humane to just send them to school in dungarees and wooden clogs with a 'kick me' sign stuck on their backs for good measure…
I'm sure that there lots of places where the majority of a class of twelve year old teens has no smartphone at all, but that is becoming rare in developed countries. Sure, if you could band together with other parents you might be able to come up with a different approach, but that's not what's happening.
Then you have this kind of endemic bullshit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13930707
Play. Get dirty. Take risks. Life is full of all of that, and most of it doesn't haunt you forever. Kids and smartphones though, it's just a bad combination.
We're doing ourselves no favors as adults, but kids really are getting the greasy end of the stick.
But yeah, the Internet never forgets.[0] Maybe people will just need to cut each other more slack.
[0] http://www.sltrib.com/home/4461113-155/kirby-the-internet-ne...