To NoScript's credit, it did block a phishing site that I otherwise would've fallen for once.
That was before the era of single-page apps. Like it or not, JavaScript is mandatory for even basic functionality on the modern web.
Telling users to introduce 4 clicks to load every new domain and potentially experience some significant breakages (e.g., I remember some checkout processes failing because they'd bounce the request around between scripts from processors, fraud prevention, etc.) just on the remote chance that they'll encounter malicious JavaScript is simply a non-starter. Something like Ghostery that mostly-transparently blocks things is a better proposition for ordinary adoption.
Why do you consider it to be so? To quote Tor Project's Mike Perry:
The reason we feel that leaving Javascript enabled trumps these concerns is:
1. We want enough people to actually use Tor Browser such that it becomes less interesting that you're a Tor user. We have plenty of academic research and mathematical proofs that tell us quite clearly that the more people use Tor, the better the privacy, anonymity, and traffic analysis resistance properties will become.
In fact, my personal goal is to grab the entire "Do Not Track" userbase from Mozilla. That userbase is probably well in excess of 12.5 million people: http://www.techworld.com.au/article/400248/
I do not believe we can capture that userbase if we ship a JS-disabled-by-default browser.
2. Exploitable vulnerabilities can be anywhere in the browser, not just in the JS interpreter. We disable and/or click-to-play the known major vectors, but the best solutions here are providing bug bounties (Mozilla does this; we should too, if we had any money) and sandboxing systems (Seatbelt, AppArmor, SELinux).
https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-talk/2012-May/024...
The needsecurity group should not have js enabled because it has been shown to be insecure (correct me if I'm wrong).
I would be happy if there was a big, red, fullscreen, flashing dialogue when tor browser was started asking the user which they were.
I would/will be happier if/when major browsers transition to 'tor as normal' status and everyone is in the providessecurity group.
I think you are trolling. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if you worked for some organization that wants to keep people off Tor.
If you want to defend you post, then explain what people should do instead of using Tails.
I don't want to keep people away from TOR, I personally don't care about TOR project as such, but I believe everyone deserved privacy. And people or companies who believe it's okay to mess with your adblock filters and promote shady malware companines, don't work for the same purpose.
It doesn't directly affect TOR, but the combination above is the most vulnerable people and if the author is fine with giving them instructions installing malware, why should a TOR user trust him? It doesn't make sense.