News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's a disease? Or: shoud fat/shy/alcoholic people be b... by DanielBMarkham on Monday May 31, 2010 @09:24AM (#1392471)
Sometimes I think all interesting questions boil down to semantics.

One nit: libertarian (classic, not anti-government) attitudes were described thusly: * People who make good decisions are intrinsically good people and deserve good treatment; people who make bad decisions are intrinsically bad people and deserve bad treatment.*

Er no. Libertarian thought tells us that variations in individuals are more important than societal standards. Not that people are "bad" or "good"

Taking a determinist consequentialist position allows us to do so more effectively.

This strikes me as the difference between an academic argument and a practical one. Academically, sure, the numbers add up. Practically, this is completely terrible advice, for the sole reason that the criteria suggested are not only indeterminate but suffer large variations as applied by different individuals. And offering up some sort of scientific committee or standards for what to blame people for is totally whacked, for reasons I'll leave as an exercise to the reader.

I liked the observation that people who condemn others may do so because others have not sacrificed. This fits intuitively with what I have observed.

I'd add another detail, though. There is a long tradition in western thought that the individual's struggles with character traits that he or she don't like has value in itself. We always should have a place we would like to be that we cannot attain. Western medicine and ideals, however, seem to feel that if we commonly view one condition as "better" or "worse" than another, some sort of chemical or social intervention is required in order to make people better. This worked great when "worse" = the plague, but the model is falling apart when "worse" = too fat. The types of structures and systems of thought we have set up for the plague do not naturally extend to shyness. The word has stretched too far.

I support looking at the necessary and sufficient conditions, but I felt the analysis was loose and incomplete, which led to a muddled set of conclusions.

Re:What's a disease? Or: shoud fat/shy/alcoholic people be b... by steveklabnik on Monday May 31, 2010 @10:23AM (#1392558)
> libertarian (classic, not anti-government)

Slightly offtopic, but did you mean 'classic liberal?' I thought original recipe libertarians were anarchists. I only ask because I only recently learned that fact, and found it interesting.

Re:What's a disease? Or: shoud fat/shy/alcoholic people be b... by DanielBMarkham on Monday May 31, 2010 @10:46AM (#1392602)
Be careful of words with political annotations -- liberal, conservative, libertarian. The problem is that there is the theory, and then there is application of the theory. For instance, "liberal" has changed quite a bit over the last hundred years, as has "conservative"

You can cherry-pick various people or parties that have called themselves liberal or conservative and come up with all sorts of positions. It's a fun parlor game, but the only thing it proves is that people can take a simple idea and twist it into all sorts of things. Doesn't mean the idea is whacked.

Libertarian is the same as the rest of them.

I'll go with first line in the wiki article The term libertarian in a metaphysical or philosophical sense was first used by late-Enlightenment free-thinkers to refer to those who believed in free will, as opposed to determinism

Historically yes, it was grabbed by anarchists. And you can find examples of libertarian "thought" being used to justify all sorts of crazy stuff. But the point here is that if you are telling me that I am good or bad, you are applying deterministic thought which implies some sort of control. Better to say that we are both free agents acting in our own best interests. If I cut off my toe, you may get very upset. What a bad thing to do! But it was my toe, and if I didn't like it, it was my right to get rid of it. Your tendency to view my actions in terms of your morality is an attempt to layer your version of deterministic morality over my right to do things which may frighten or offend you. The next step would be for you to start labeling my toe-cutting a form of sickness that society would be justified in "fixing" for me.

It's exactly the same thing as the church did, it's just dressed up in science and medicine instead of religion and myth.

Re:What's a disease? Or: shoud fat/shy/alcoholic people be b... by steveklabnik on Monday May 31, 2010 @11:00AM (#1392620)
Thanks for the well-thought out response. You touch on a subject that I find to be really interesting, in a game-theory sort of way: words are always changing, that's the nature of language. Yet in order to have reasoned discourse, we need to nail down what words actually mean. There's a certain push and pull that goes on between those two sides, I guess, which is why it's so hard to talk about these things. Everyone has different meanings for everything.
Re:What's a disease? Or: shoud fat/shy/alcoholic people be b... by loewenskind on Monday May 31, 2010 @10:34AM (#1392576)
In the US "libertarian" means something different than it does... everywhere else.
Re:What's a disease? Or: shoud fat/shy/alcoholic people be b... by brazzy on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @02:09AM (#1394460)
I don't think "libertarian" is used much outside the US. liberal, on the other hand, is definitely a word whose connotations in the US seem bizarre to anyone outside.