Do you have any citations for that? There are a number of studies linked at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effectiveness_of_Alcoholics_Ano... suggesting conflicting results.
This varies with personality and situation - I know exactly what you mean because I was shouted at for being fat and lazy as a child and it never did any good, but I can also think of many situations in my own life where the opposite was true and people yelling at me for failing provided the impetus to do better...
I think the risk of not doing anything is worse though. If poor behaviour is tolerated, and not given some kind of negative feedback then it can become accepted. I suspect this is part of the obesity problem - if living as a fat person were really horrible less people would be inclined to do it and, at the risk of sounding cruel, if medical help were refused for obesity related problems then the genetic element would take care of itself...
I'm fat - and if I die because my heart clogs up with all the byproducts of that fatness then it is my own /stupid/ fault.
Yep, absolutely. Maybe it's that I listened to too much punk rock as a kid, but I have this odd personality trait where if someone criticizes me for something that I consider illegitimate, I get this instant, visceral "fuck you" response, and their critique does me no good.
In other cases, I take too much to heart.
Human emotions are silly, fragile things.
Punishment is the trickiest of all behavioral modification techniques. It is very likely to backfire, which makes perfect sense. If punishment was very effective on a given individual, he/she would be a perfect slave. Being a perfect slave isn't so great from the perspective of the slave, though it is good for the master. Since human biology doesn't make it easy for a large population of slaves to be related to a master, it makes perfect sense that we'd evolve defenses against punishment. (By contrast, ants and honeybees are all children of their queen, so their arrangement makes perfect evolutionary sense.)
One psych teacher of mine pointed out the behavior of Wile E. Coyote as plausible -- often punishment of a complex organism can result in the subject trying again and again in different ways, despite punishment, particularly if there is a possible reward to be gained.
Oh, been there, done that. :)
I used to despise the people who would give me grief for smoking. They were wasting their time, and it was none of their fucking business.
Later, after I quit smoking, it occurred to me that those admonitions helped. Much as I hated to accept that, the regular jibes kept alive the idea of quitting.
I hate being told what to do, especially if it's coupled with the idea that what I'm currently doing is both wrong and stupid, but that's just pride.
I didn't quit smoking because people told me to, but having people constantly tell me to quit did help keep the idea percolating in the back of my head, a contribution to my finally coming to terms with what needed to be done and mustering the reserve to just do it.
There's the risk that some people will spite themselves just to show the world how independent they are, and the more you tell them what that must do, the less likely they are to do it. But provoking people into reconsidering their actions, even if it annoys them, may help in the long run.
Basically, so long as I knew I had the option to smoke I was way more inclined to want to do so, and found it harder to resist. This was sort of encouraging, because it suggested that a lot of the urge was psychological, which seemed better than a relentless chemistry-driven compulsion I might never beat.
That's not to deny the physical addiction part, but to note that appreciating that it's not all physical addiction makes it seem less impossible to beat.
(I also noticed that the urge to smoke in the morning was greater after I had that first one. I then started throwing any remaining cigs down the toilet before going to sleep. That took will power. :) Sure, I would buy smokes on the way to work, or at lunch time, but it helped me cut down. I must say, addiction sucks.)
Recognizing this is central, hence the "Hi, I'm Bob, and I'm an alcoholic."
You're never cured and return to drinking socially... (ideally) you don't ever drink. Ever. Whether publicly or not, you refer to yourself as an alcoholic so it's always clear to you what the deal is, and you don't fool yourself.
The permanence of it feels harsh to me, but it does seem to work, perhaps because "admitting the problem" is so important.
None of this, in reality, is based on science or facts. It is something that the original progenitors made up.
Because most people in their normal lives will not develop an addiction firsthand, and because most people are honest and basically believe what they are told (expecting other people to tell them the truth), this continues to propagate.
One way to tell if something propagates mostly as a meme rather than by functional merit is to cross cultural boundaries and look for it elsewhere. If it were something that had merit, there is a better chance for it to have grown within other cultures independently. AA's own self-published census shows that it is overwhelmingly an American and Canadian phenomenon, with some small sprinkling in the UK. It basically exists nowhere else in the world, except for expatriates from the US.
There is also a correlation between alcohol addiction and AA penetration. Places with more problems with alcohol addiction have more AA meetings. At first this seems to make sense -- more alcoholics, more AA members and meetings to help them. But if you go to places where AA does not exist at all, you'll find the same numbers you'd expect from America if there was no correlation with AA. In other words, places without AA have the same numbers you would get in America if you took the AA slider widget and turned it back down to 0.
My own conclusion is that AA and alcoholism is mostly a cultural artifact, not a physical (or 'spiritual') disease manifesting itself in people's bodies. I encourage you to dig up numbers (which AA openly provides from their own surveys, and are not flattering to themselves) and draw your own conclusions.
Well, what you hear may vary from one AA group to the next, but I don't think the core point is that it is spiritual, only that it is permanent. (Assorted official books from AA may say otherwise, but actual AA groups very in the application of the key principles.)
The idea is that some people keep chasing the idea that they can drink just a little then stop, yet fail again and again. If you can get them to just give up on that idea they'll be better off.
"AA's own self-published census shows that it is overwhelmingly an American and Canadian phenomenon, with some small sprinkling in the UK. It basically exists nowhere else in the world, except for expatriates from the US."
Do you have a link for this? These sites suggests otherwise:
Yes I do.
Outside of U.S./Canada
704,266 Members
Total Reported
2,103,033 Members
In other words, 33% of all AA membership is not within North America. This is from their own material, the 2007 survey. http://www.aa.org/en_pdfs/m-24_aafactfile.pdf33%? That's still a lot, right?
Occurrence of AA membership in North America: 1 in 265
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(population+of+united+s...
Occurrence of AA membership the world, excluding North America: 1 in 9207
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(population+of+world+-+...
It makes sense that their international presence is played up heavily on their sites and other material, so as to make it seem as if they are expounding some universal truth, rather than a localized phenomenon.
The idea is that some people keep chasing the idea that they can drink just a little then stop, yet fail again and again. If you can get them to just give up on that idea they'll be better off.
Yes, that is one of AA's core ideas, and not backed up by scientific research or studies. Just because a lot of people (where you live) say it very loudly and frequently does not make it true. This is exactly what I just talked about in my previous post -- people accept these statements as if they are inherently true, without examining them critically.
I'm unfamiliar with the program enough that I can't refute the word "spiritual", though another viewpoint might be that alcoholism might rewire your brain permanently, which is conceivable imho.
Honestly, I think it is something of an excuse to live with the problem (I'm not judging on that, fair enough). A coping mechanism, if you will, to live with relapses and so forth.
I know at least one Alcoholic who is totally dry now (and will not touch a drink because he is scared of slipping back) and yet another who is a normal drinker again. In the first case the guy is pretty like those in the AA - but his coping mechanism is to have scared himself from drinking (again, no issue there - if it works...). The final example, though, suggests that alcoholism is entirely fixable in at least some cases.
(note: I've had problems with slightly excessive/impulsive/habitual drinking in the fairly recent past, so some of this is from experience)
Take alcoholism. The most effective treatment today for alcoholism is AA. (there are many thing about aa that kind of creep me out, but it is a fact that it has the highest success rate of any course of treatment that has been studied). AA works almost entirely through social influence. But a key component of its social influence is talking about alcoholism as a disease, as something separate from an individual which can be done away with. Talking about alcoholism as a moral failing simply does not help. If you are morally bankrupt, what are the odds of your morally bankrupt self digging your way out of that hole? If you have a disease, though, maybe you can find a cure.
Similarly, as a child, people yelling at me that I was a lazy bum just didn't help. My primary reaction was resentment, not shame. Though I had shame, too. Its just not so easy to motivate oneself when feeling like a shameful failure. When I started thing of laziness as a behavior that I happened to have, rather than something that was intrinsic to myself, (i.e., I am being lazy right now, what can I do about it, as opposed to I am lazy), I started being able to have more control over it. Not perfect control, of course, but much more than I had.