News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BP Knew of Deepwater Horizon Problems 11 Months Ago by loewenskind on Monday May 31, 2010 @07:06AM (#1392307)
Well, if BP were exposed to the full liability here they would simply go out of business. I don't know about you, but personally I would rather people are prevented from killing me. Punishing them after the fact doesn't do me any good.

Your solution actually still seems to still call for regulation, just by a private company instead of the government. I would submit that there isn't a problem having government do the regulation, the problem would simply be having the US government doing them.

Re:BP Knew of Deepwater Horizon Problems 11 Months Ago by dantheman on Monday May 31, 2010 @08:25AM (#1392399)
Any government doing the regulation has perverse incentives. The main effect of government regulation is to keep entrenched business successful and keep out new competition -- regulatory capture. The government has to do a balancing act because it doesn't compensate the victim and it doesn't want to drive businesses out of town -- how much regulation is too much, how much is too little.

Look at how the FDA works -- they have nothing to lose when the deny a drug, and a lot hassle when the approve a drug that turns out to be harmful. This is why so many potentially effective drugs sit on the shelf waiting for further tests.