Re:BP Knew of Deepwater Horizon Problems 11 Months Ago
by dantheman on Monday May 31, 2010 @08:25AM
(#1392399)
Any government doing the regulation has perverse incentives. The main effect of government regulation is to keep entrenched business successful and keep out new competition -- regulatory capture. The government has to do a balancing act because it doesn't compensate the victim and it doesn't want to drive businesses out of town -- how much regulation is too much, how much is too little.
Look at how the FDA works -- they have nothing to lose when the deny a drug, and a lot hassle when the approve a drug that turns out to be harmful. This is why so many potentially effective drugs sit on the shelf waiting for further tests.
Your solution actually still seems to still call for regulation, just by a private company instead of the government. I would submit that there isn't a problem having government do the regulation, the problem would simply be having the US government doing them.