Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on The Logic Behind Japanese Sentence Structure. Parent comment
"anata ga kukkii wo taberu no wo mita yo" (I saw you eat the cookie)
"Anata" is now the subject of a subordinate clause.
I think it can be topicalized (in the sense of becoming the grammatical topic, marked by ha) like this:
"Anata ha, kukkii wo taberu no wo mita yo". (As for you, I saw (you) eat the cookie.)
The subordinate clause now has an unspecified/implicit subject, and that identifies with the topic that was introduced.
I think an extraposition of "anata" (into a non-topical position) is possible like this, where subordinate clause minus its subject is now the topic:
"kukkii wo taberu no wo mita ha, anata da yo". (the one I saw eating the cookie is you)
There are no comments on this comment yet.
"anata ga kukkii wo taberu no wo mita yo" (I saw you eat the cookie)
"Anata" is now the subject of a subordinate clause.
I think it can be topicalized (in the sense of becoming the grammatical topic, marked by ha) like this:
"Anata ha, kukkii wo taberu no wo mita yo". (As for you, I saw (you) eat the cookie.)
The subordinate clause now has an unspecified/implicit subject, and that identifies with the topic that was introduced.
I think an extraposition of "anata" (into a non-topical position) is possible like this, where subordinate clause minus its subject is now the topic:
"kukkii wo taberu no wo mita ha, anata da yo". (the one I saw eating the cookie is you)