News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by fmihaila on Monday March 20, 2017 @04:45PM (#13917513)
> Do planets ever stop rotating?

Of course they do, on an appropriately long time scale. First they stop rotating around their own axis due to tidal forces, after which they lose the remaining kinetic energy to the gravitational waves emitted by their rotation around the star (again, on a very long time scale, but not infinite).

2nd EDIT: <removed gratuitous reference to moderation>.

Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by Nomentatus on Monday March 20, 2017 @09:16PM (#13919016)
Not gravitational waves (you're thinking caused by solar flares moving at the surface of the sun) - but the particle radiation from the sun will continue to slow planets over time.
Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by fmihaila on Monday March 20, 2017 @09:42PM (#13919131)
> Not gravitational waves.

Yes, gravitational waves.

You are correct that in the case of the Earth, other causes will lead to its demise long before said waves would amount to any significant effect. But even in an ideal case where a single planet like the Earth revolved around, say, a black hole with the same mass as the Sun, which would emit no particles, it would still not orbit indefinitely due to the energy lost to gravitational waves emitted as a result of its revolution around another body. The amount of energy lost in one revolution is tiny, but is not zero (according to this calculation [0], for the Sun-Earth system it amounts to about 200W).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_wave#Power_radia...

Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by Nomentatus on Monday March 20, 2017 @11:26PM (#13919634)
Yes, two bodies create a gravitational wave that affects other bodies - but I don't see how those variations represent work - and they aren't observable on the two bodies themselves, so one wouldn't expect any effect upon those two bodies. Throw in the other planets and you might have a better argument, for example that Jupiter-Sun waves affect earth. Still, gravity "waves" aren't like water waves, as far as we yet know they don't represent (changes in) the impact of particles. However if you wish to argue that Higg's Bosons mediate gravity (some have, I believe) this objection of mine might be overcome. In other words, though I might be wrong, I just don't think we're at the point where we can deduce friction from gravitational waves, and we certainly aren't at the point where we can empirically measure such friction (as opposed to the "wave" - variation in gravitational field.)

PS, sorry: there should have been a question mark in my previous post asking whether you were thinking about flares.

Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @03:55AM (#13920498)
> I just don't think we're at the point where we can deduce friction from gravitational waves

Where do you think the energy we measure in a gravitational wave comes from? The whole concept arose to explain the last parsec problem of orbital collapse.

Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by Nomentatus on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @10:44PM (#13928115)
There is a change in gravity, true - but a net slowing is another matter. That an explanation of X was needed doesn't justify any sufficient-if-true explanation Y.
Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by fmihaila on Monday March 20, 2017 @11:50PM (#13919749)
> Yes, two bodies create a gravitational wave that affects other bodies - but I don't see how those variations represent work - and they aren't observable on the two bodies themselves, so one wouldn't expect any effect upon those two bodies

The lost energy results in orbital decay, eventually leading to the two bodies colliding. The page I linked to explains it in more detail.

Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by Nomentatus on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @12:39AM (#13919909)
Asserts it, yes - but my last sentence still applies. We don't have a fine-grained understanding of gravity; we'd need it for such a deduction. As it happens, I don't think we've ruled out that gravity itself - not just waves - slowly decays orbits. I rather expect this to be so, in fact, but on the basis of an eccentric theory of gravity.
Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by maxerickson on Monday March 20, 2017 @04:51PM (#13917558)
BTW, I find it amusing that people take internet points away because they think the laws of thermodynamics apply only in certain circumstances.

They do only apply to closed systems.

(which information we are unable to ascertain about our universe)

Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by jacquesm on Monday March 20, 2017 @04:56PM (#13917587)
It's better than that: the fact that the universe even exists implies that at some point there was either a violation of this law or it is part of a larger closed system within which the law still holds.
Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by roywiggins on Monday March 20, 2017 @05:03PM (#13917628)
Or, there is no minimum entropy, and no matter how far back you look there's more entropy. Maybe the Big Bang is an illusion and before the big bang, there was even less entropy, and on and on infinitely into the past.
Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by dandelany on Monday March 20, 2017 @05:05PM (#13917654)
Which is like saying "I can swing forever as long as someone keeps pushing me." Clearly true, but pedantic and irrelevant to the discussion.
Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll... by maxerickson on Monday March 20, 2017 @05:10PM (#13917695)
Pedantic needling is always a relevant response to internet point outrage.