News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go To University, Not For CS by acangiano on Sunday May 30, 2010 @08:10PM (#1391385)
> Another way to explain the shallowness of Computer Science

> is that it's the only discipline that eschews paradox.

> Even mathematics has reams of unanswered questions and

> potential paradox in its core philosophy. In Computer

> Science, there's none. It's assumed that all of it is

> pretty much solved and your job as an undergraduate is

> to just learn to get a job in this totally solved area

> of expertise.

Zed is confusing software engineering with computer science. CS is a branch of applied mathematics, and it's not different from mathematics. There are unsolved problems and plenty of areas that require further research.

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by robryan on Sunday May 30, 2010 @08:15PM (#1391394)
It's not like software engineering doesn't have unsolved problems either, like why is it still so hard to produce bug free software, why programmer productivity has only gone up a small amount despite 30 years of language advances and why most software still has to be mostly custom. The dream from the earlier days of software engineering where we were eventually meant to have components that could easily be mixed and matched to create whatever we want hasn't eventuated.
Re:Go To University, Not For CS by rbranson on Sunday May 30, 2010 @08:33PM (#1391426)
I don't think we'll ever get around having to build software with code and highly trained developers. The world is still very much custom engineered, from architecture to civil engineering, electrical to mechanical engineering, even mass produced items have relatively few interchangeable parts.
Re:Go To University, Not For CS by prosa on Sunday May 30, 2010 @08:49PM (#1391455)
I agree. However, it is worth examining places like Dubai -- the tallest building in the world, and indeed practically an entire new city, was built by unskilled laborers working for dollars a day.

That's a compelling case for commoditization of talent, but in the end I think it's just a heuristic improvement. It gets you pretty far, but at the end of the day you still have huge teams of PhDs and M.Archs doing the actual engineering. (If that was commoditized it would be a scary world indeed!)

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by rbanffy on Sunday May 30, 2010 @10:07PM (#1391591)
> an entire new city, was built by unskilled laborers working for dollars a day.

Let's see if it's still standing a couple decades from now.

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by werrett on Sunday May 30, 2010 @11:36PM (#1391724)
>> an entire new city, was built by unskilled laborers working for dollars a day.

> Let's see if it's still standing a couple decades from now.

I didn't realise that it was solely teams of skilled engineers and artisans doing the riveting on Empire State back in 1930.

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by rbanffy on Monday May 31, 2010 @08:09AM (#1392381)
You do, of course, understand how over-engineered is the Empire State by today's standards.

I seriously doubt 30's margins are still being applied.

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by jrockway on Sunday May 30, 2010 @08:23PM (#1391409)
Yeah, I'm not sure I agree with him at all. I would say that the human race knows approximately nothing about building software. Yeah, we can do it, but we're not very good at it. If bridges and buildings were software, we would have all died in collapsing buildings and the human race would be extinct.
Re:Go To University, Not For CS by scorpion032 on Monday May 31, 2010 @03:56AM (#1392060)
Software is built the way to collapse _because_ it's not like brides and people don't lose lives if it collapses.

A little bit of Darwin, on why things are the way they are.

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by jrockway on Monday May 31, 2010 @04:46AM (#1392124)
Re:Go To University, Not For CS by hga on Monday May 31, 2010 @11:14AM (#1392649)
Given that the flight recorders were tampered with I can't see how you can be so sure it was caused by software.

Frankly, anyone flying at a low speed and very low altitude (which I define here as few hundred feet) with jet engines at idle needs to have their head examined. Whatever the software did or didn't do, the pilots knew all of these details and that with their craft's low energy level and the engines spooled down they had little or no margin for error, their's or the new (less than one and half years since first flight) fly-by-wire software.

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by scott_s on Sunday May 30, 2010 @08:27PM (#1391417)
Re:Go To University, Not For CS by shadowsun7 on Monday May 31, 2010 @02:14AM (#1391935)
Abso-blooming-lutely. Whatever happened to NP-Complete as an icky problem nobody can solve? That's exclusive to computer science right there.
Re:Go To University, Not For CS by astrec on Sunday May 30, 2010 @08:43PM (#1391443)
Seems to be talking more about Software Engineering, Business Systems, and Information Technology degrees which started to replace CS (and the awesome CS/Philosophy double) during the late 90s.

You can test the depth of CS for yourself when you take your first formal methods course.

Re:Go To University, Not For CS by j_baker on Monday May 31, 2010 @10:03AM (#1392524)
Erm... Not to say too much, but I'm pretty sure mathematicians would envy CS not having paradoxes.