I want to reply to you but I am too tired to make a proper well thought out reply. So I will keep it short.
I agree with you, and there is a whole lot of stuff to talk about with regards to this (far too much for me to type right now).
As pointed out in my previous reply on this topic, I have indeed stacked the table to one side to help illustrate my point.
I really want to talk more about schooling with regards to this subject of learning and assessing one's knowledge retention. But it is far too late :(
However insofar as there's a limit to every principle, I would caution against a too-generic approach 100% of the time: it's often after a second step in which you learn, often by heart (think hobby, think things you love), a bunch of very detailed information about a topic, that you truly feel confident about your knowledge. And this is what we generally define as expertise (albeit 2nd degree until you make things, apply this knowledge). In most cases, it comes with time and exposure (experience, repetition) but is much accelerated by a conscious will to learn (and good methods).
In short, a high-level ontological approach combined with a sizeable degree of freedom to explore this or that topic in ample detail (quite lacking in studies where you have to rush everything).