You probably haven't studied much or any AI. In my opinion, those who haven't researched a subject don't understand the details and are likely to make more inaccurate predictions than experts.
In the past 50 years, AI has seen hundreds of small successes in narrow tasks that used to require humans. But none so far has shown the potential to scale up, generalize, and serve tasks other than the narrow one for which it was designed. Like IBM Watson, AlphaGo too is likely to be consigned to the AI scrapheap in the sky.
BUT... the deep net technique used by AlphaGo shows more promise to solve the remaining unsolved AI tasks than any AI method before it. Yes, we still don't know DL's limits, like whether it can integrate one-shot learning, or build and reuse a diverse knowledgebase, or transfer specific methods to solve new more general problems. But as of right now, it's shown greater promise to solve novel weak AI tasks than any past technique I've seen. The author overlooks that potential deliberately and provocatively, and IMO, pointlessly.
Can DL scale up into strong AI too? I think the important thing here isn't that the answer isn't obviously yes (as the author posits), but that the answer isn't obviously no. And in the 50+ year quest for strong AI, that's a first, at least for me.
It would be self-serving if I lied in an interview and said I was qualified for a job making robots if I'd never had any experience doing so.
This is just a short title, and ITT people didn't read the first paragraph.
So it uses a strong claim — i.e. AlphaGo is not AI — then subsequently changes it to a smaller claim — AlphaGo is not AGI.
Reading the entire article does not change the fact that this can be seen as a technique to attract readers. Claim rare X; change X to be a subset of Y; then claim it was really new X all along. Moving the goal post.
With respect, you are being pedantic.
I think that's what the author was thinking when he wrote the title, and I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt.
I'm being flexible, not picky. Disagree with me? Fine, I really don't care.
I could guess that he didn't use a qualifier because there are many different ones and none universally accepted. Or, maybe he wanted to reach a non-tech audience who wouldn't know the difference between strong AI and AI.
There are plenty of good reasons, and reading the article clarifies the author's meaning.
Perhaps we need a new term to refer to "true" AI, preferably one that matches people's general notions of what an AI should be. "Synthetic Thought" maybe?
It's a response to people who think because of AlphaGo that we are on the cusp of achieving true / strong / general AI.
> An AI that solves a lot of problems better than humans, and transfers that learning across many problems with relative ease, is getting close to strong AI.
We're not close. See Yann LeCun's statement on AI after AlphaGo [1] and the HN response [2]
[1] https://www.facebook.com/yann.lecun/posts/10153426023477143
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11280744