News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by nazgulnarsil on Monday March 17, 2008 @02:38PM (#139099)
It's getting scary. It's not that we're going to have robots going haywire and killing people on its own. It's that the elite crust of humanity is going to use it againstt us. Think blackwater is bad now? How about when they're not even human beings?

The thing keeping the elites in check for all of human history has been that they can't get too crazy or their own soldiers will mutiny. Hitler was a study in charismatic leadership. He was able to commit atrocities only because the german populace liked him so much. WHat attrocities will be possible when it is impossible for your soldiers to disobey?

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by yummyfajitas on Monday March 17, 2008 @05:08PM (#139226)
>Think blackwater is bad now? How about when they're not even human beings?

Then they run at a lower threat level.

A humans's decision process: "Is that guy a suicide bomber? OMFG SHOOT!" A few minutes later: "Fuck sarge, I got scared. I screwed up big time."

A robot's decision process:

    if uncertain_of_hostility(target):
        speaker.warning() #This robot only costs us $50,000. Hearts and minds, right?
    else:
        fire_warning_shot(target, bystanders)

    ## if fu_bar(target): #Don't delete or uncomment this line, or else bad things will happen.
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by thorax on Monday March 17, 2008 @03:50PM (#139152)
That's when the hackers here step in, right?
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by sabat on Monday March 17, 2008 @03:51PM (#139156)
As long as hacking without a license remains legal.
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by SwellJoe on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @03:58AM (#139680)
Sense. Your comment makes none.

Hackers (or crackers, if you prefer) don't wait for permission.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by sabat on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @02:54PM (#140059)
Direct object. Your sentences use it unconventionally.

Anyway, I was being wry. You may not be waiting for permission, but it does matter if it's illegal.

(Clarification: I use hacking in the same spirit as this site, meaning to code with a hobbyist's or experimenter's ethic. Not meaning the media obfuscation of the word.)

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @01:38AM (#139606)
many issues in the next few decades will involve technology outrunning our ability to make ethical choices about their uses. what will the ultimate effects be of crops with terminator genes be? what happens when biotech created in a lab winds up mutating out in the wild? human cloning and genetically tailored babies are great examples that are emerging right now.

of these robots being used as somewhat intelligent disposable soldiers scares me the most because it is the easiest to abuse and the effects would be felt immediately. when it becomes a matter of pressing a button to suppress an uprising, who will decide when it is appropriate to press that button? remember that winners get called freedom fighters and losers get called terrorists. The USA wouldn't exist today if our "freedom fighters" hadn't resisted british rule.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by 1gor on Monday March 17, 2008 @04:08PM (#139172)
What's scary is how much this comment reminds me of Reddit...
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by euccastro on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @12:33AM (#139560)
To be honest, I'm quite tired of all this "ugh, this is so reddit!" I wish people would discuss the (de)merits of comments in their own terms.
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by 1gor on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @02:20AM (#139638)
OK. I'll explain why it reminds me of reddit.

The author of the comment in question uses tired populist cliché (elites) and tries to impose their own political views on the reader (you think blackwater is bad).

Which is likely to generate a long, heated and shallow political debate rather than a discussion about the technology (or about the social implications of the technology).

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by rms on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @02:41AM (#139653)
Blackwater being bad is not a political view; it is close to moral truth. I have talked to multiple US soldiers back from Iraq who have described Blackwater committing what would normally be war crimes. However, Blackwater is not subject to laws, so they're not war crimes.
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by rms on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @05:23AM (#139700)
Details of one of the incidents:

Soldier was in the Air Force, in northern Iraq near the Iranian border. They had a warrant to raid a house looking for a weapons cache. They did the raid with some guys from Blackwater. When they got inside, there was a guy laying on the couch watching TV. Normally, anyone inside a house during a raid would be put in flexcuffs. A guy from Blackwater just shot him, while he was laying on the couch.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by nazgulnarsil on Monday March 17, 2008 @09:59PM (#139455)
I understand, i'm usually against conspiracy theory bullshit myself. using robots on the battlefield is the only subject I get a little spooked over.
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by astine on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @12:38AM (#139566)
Robots on the battlefield doesn't spook me at all. It seems to me to be an improvement over sending people to risk their lives.
Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by SwellJoe on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @04:07AM (#139684)
"It seems to me to be an improvement over sending people to risk their lives."

So, who are the robots fighting then if not people? I'm just thinking what a frightening thing it would be for an empire builder like GWB to have a conscience-less army of mechanical killers. At least our armed forces generally want to avoid killing innocents. Big Dogs with M50 machine guns don't care about such fine distinctions. So, yes, it could be scary.

Now, of course, as soon as these are available to the general public, I fully intend to exercise my second amendment right to own robotic death machines. That's in the constitution, right?

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by gills on Tuesday March 18, 2008 @12:53PM (#139943)
Because maybe, just MAYBE, when we realize our robots are fighting their robots and it's really just an expensive video game, we'll quit fighting and actually sit down and talk.

That is, if the robots don't join forces and turn on us first.

oops..spelling edit.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by motley_fool on Wednesday March 19, 2008 @09:03PM (#141291)
Nonsense. People don't sit down and talk when they have less to lose. They negotiate when they have more to lose.

So what will actually happen is that these ultra-tech tools will just further shield voters from the nastiness of war, and allow their leaders to visit horror on those less technologically advanced.

What I'd like to see happen is the creation of some kind of independent news agency that uses UAV and robot technologies to bring back uncensored, uninvited news back from warzones. Of course if this were truly effective, that news agency itself would become a target.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by motley_fool on Wednesday March 19, 2008 @08:59PM (#141287)
This is an overly simplistic and dangerous view of warfare. Increasingly, warfare is not about soldiers being sent to fight each other in some empty battlefield.

The pattern of U.S. wars since WWII has been expeditionary warfare where the U.S. sends its troops to fight with irregular forces, among civilians of other countries.

No war is clean, but this is a particularly evil setup, because the worst that American non-combatants experience is the return of their dead or wounded troops. On the other hand, the host country feels the full horror of war.

So, frankly, I don't care nearly as much about the volunteers who are sent to risk their lives as the civilian non-volunteers who are necessarily and inevitably harmed.

This is not a U.S. specific thing. It's just that as citizens of the top military power, Americans are spared the full horrors of war, yet have the ability to visit those horrors on others.

There is a reason why Europeans are not nearly as accepting of warfare.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by astine on Thursday March 20, 2008 @03:26PM (#141860)
The reason Europeans are not as accepting of warfare is because they screwed themselves over twice with it. War is always the last resort of negotiation. When nations become too belligerent or stubborn conflict will always follow. Europe forgot this lesson twice in as many generations and suffered the consequences.

There are only two ways to prevent conflict: 1. be reasonable in all of your negotiations and 2. make sure you are always ready for a conflict.

If you fail to do the first, others may see no choice but to fight you. If you fail to do the second, they may not see any downside to it. This boils down to one principle, you must always back every one of your demands, even the reasonable one which you have a right to, with sufficient force.

In short, there is nothing wrong with using machines to do our fighting for us. There is something wrong with killing civilians and unnecessarily invading foreign countries; but there is nothing wrong with using better weapons to do the same job.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by motley_fool on Saturday March 22, 2008 @09:36PM (#143712)
> There is something wrong with killing civilians and unnecessarily invading foreign countries; but there is nothing wrong with using better weapons to do the same job.

You're assuming that these two issues are independent. I'm proposing that handing our rulers robot warriors will result in harder-to-expose killing of civilians and more unnecessary invasions.

Of course, if all the killer robots were working for me, I would deploy them wisely and reduce civilians deaths.

Re:New Video of BigDog Quadruped Robot Is So Stunning It's S... by angstrom on Monday March 17, 2008 @10:35PM (#139482)
On a long enough timeline every discussion on the Internet converges on Hitler and Nazis.