Re:I will not log in to your website
by mcguire on Sunday March 19, 2017 @10:28AM
(#13907247)
The process, as I've experienced it, is:
1. Authors write paper.
2. Authors send paper to journal or conference address. (...using a web form)
3. The editor gives the paper a once-over and decides to send it out for review.
4. (Editor sends links to reviewers, who log in, read paper, and leave comments.)
5. Lather, rinse, repeat until accept/reject decision is made.
They used to send pdfs, but now use web systems for roughly the same reason HN isn't a mailing list.
Note: the last time anyone let me review a paper was a long time ago, when they sent paper forms to fill out. Parts in (...) are how I assume it works now.
1. Authors write paper.
2. Authors send paper to journal or conference address. (...using a web form)
3. The editor gives the paper a once-over and decides to send it out for review.
4. (Editor sends links to reviewers, who log in, read paper, and leave comments.)
5. Lather, rinse, repeat until accept/reject decision is made.
They used to send pdfs, but now use web systems for roughly the same reason HN isn't a mailing list.
Note: the last time anyone let me review a paper was a long time ago, when they sent paper forms to fill out. Parts in (...) are how I assume it works now.