But the pledge was just a formality - should there be any interest to check the mail, there was nothing technically stopping anyone with the required access except for someone else with equal access having a problem with it. Likewise, various management offices had no issue with submitting email fetch requests for the simplest of things, with date ranges exceeding two or three years sometimes for what turned out to be incredibly minor reasons.
There really is no expectation of privacy with academia in the US when it comes to University owned property or services.
(The only reason I found out about any of this from legal was because I asked for clarification on our "duty to report", and one of the lawyers was almost excited as he told me about how we own everything legally.)
At my company we trust our people and have a web of review. However, we try never to have anyone be the final trusted party - even the boss.
And if you want to take matters into your own hands, you use PGP. But outside of the computer security business I guess that's mostly unused.