News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tim Bray's thoughts on the BP disaster by jdietrich on Sunday May 30, 2010 @11:41AM (#1390613)
I think Bray is absolutely right to suggest that it's churlish to blame one corporation for the inevitable consequences of our energy consumption. We all like to turn a blind eye to how energy is produced, but ultimately it is a dirty business, whether that dirt is in the form of spilled oil, nuclear waste or conflict over rare earth metals. I certainly hadn't heard of a blowout protector a few weeks ago and I don't imagine too many of you had either. Much like sausage and laws, I think we just don't like to think about how our energy is made.

California's ongoing electricity crisis is the obvious example - given the choice, we tend to point-blank oppose the production of energy in spite of our own consumption. The economist Robin Hanson likes to talk of the modern age as being a sort of Dreamtime, a collective delusion more real than reality itself. I think our attitudes to energy are the most obvious element of this delusion. Most people reading this will live long enough to see us use the last of our gas, coal and oil, but we seem blissfully unaware of how dependent we are on these dwindling resources. The fact that oil prices have fallen substantially since the start of the Deepwater spill suggests to me that we have a completely myopic perspective on the value of our energy reseres.

Of course we should push to produce energy in safer and cleaner ways, but I think we all must come to terms with the fact that our energy consumption has inevitable negative consequences. If nothing else, we are consuming it at a completely unsustainable rate and none of us really have a workable plan for the future - if you think you know what the answer to our energy future is, I strongly recommend looking over Dr MacKay's book Energy Policy Without the Hot Air, which sets out in plain numbers just what a difficult problem we face. http://www.withouthotair.com/

There are no comments on this comment yet.