Oops, you're right, the other phones are not AMOLED. I had assumed they were, for some reason.
I don't doubt the resolution on the iPhone HD/4g will be better than the Nexus One. I just don't think that the non-rectangular pixel grid on the Nexus One is a huge drawback at that DPI.
This is going to seem like a really silly conversation in 10 years, when technology has moved on.
Also, don't fall into their rhetorical trap. The irregular grid may well be better, and the difference may well be visible at current iPhone resolution and be positive in AMOLEDs direction. This may, or may not, become less true as the next iPhone doubles height and width, but I'm not going to assume anything based on Appleinsider's take on the matter.
I don't think anyone's linked yet to the very in-depth Ars Technica article that looked into this screen technology:
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/news/2010/03/secrets-of-the-n...
spoiler: the 800x480 RGBG screen could be considered equivalent to a 653x392 RGB one, and regarding the iPhone:
The Nexus One screen remains better than the iPhone screen for text reproduction because the overall resolution is much higher, even taking into account the factors I describe. So if the iPhone is your measuring stick, the N1 screen really rocks. Overall, the N1 display is beautiful and vivid with dark blacks and incredible photo reproduction.
So this screen (and other standard screens with 800x480 pixels such as the Droid he mentions in the article) had leapfrogged the iPhone. A new iPhone will be out soon, that it appears will leapfrog these screens. Welcome to technology.