News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by petercooper on Saturday March 18, 2017 @08:23AM (#13900968)
I'm just going to listen to my body. Had the blood test twice, negative both times, yet after years of isolation diets and experimentation, it's gluten that gives me diarrhoea and eczema and by not eating it, I'm fine. The doctors I spoke to before I worked out the cause just said "oh it's IBS, you'll just have to manage it".. except by giving up gluten I'm 100% fine, ha!

I appreciate "hipsters" who avoid gluten because they help increase the variety of gluten free food options, but I'd just go paleo if it went away because the sickness isn't worth it.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by cgh on Saturday March 18, 2017 @09:41AM (#13901180)
It's likely FODMAPs: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FODMAP

These are found in foods that coincidentally also contain gluten and there's a demonstrated effect on digestion.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by tssva on Saturday March 18, 2017 @09:53AM (#13901226)
Exactly this. Most of the foods people with "gluten sensitivity" start to avoid also happen to be triggers for IBS which is most likely their real issue.
Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by jamesrcole on Saturday March 18, 2017 @11:23AM (#13901636)
You claim it's likely FODMAPs. What's your evidence for that?
Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by basch on Saturday March 18, 2017 @05:28PM (#13903616)
the guy who first brought up gluten sensitivity recanted and now cites FODMAPs as the likely cause. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23648697

which happens to be the article your commenting on to begin with!, just for some reason a dupe from two years later. its in the first sentence of the abstract.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by jamesrcole on Sunday March 19, 2017 @04:43PM (#13909505)
I have a friend who strictly follows a low FODMAP diet, so I'm fairly familiar with it. The thing is, if you are following a strict gluten-free diet it is very likely you are eating lots of high-FODMAP foods! (have a look at http://www.ibsdiets.org/fodmap-diet/fodmap-food-list/ for example, if you want to check it out for yourself).

So I don't see how "avoiding gluten" could be confused with FODMAP issues in most cases.

Also, as I've posted in another comment, there's been more recent research, in a reputable journal, which has found a biological explanation of wheat sensitivity. See this article for a write-up: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/07/160726123632.h...

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by basch on Monday March 20, 2017 @05:25PM (#13917795)
the article you posted is for Wheat, not Gluten (a protein)

do you see how it is incorrect to attribute a problem to an ingredient, when a different ingredient in the Wheat may be causing the problem?

Maybe it's just semantics, but blaming gluten when it likely is something besides gluten seems wrong. Gluten is not a synonym for Wheat.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by jamesrcole on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @07:20PM (#13927177)
> do you see how it is incorrect to attribute a problem to an ingredient, when a different ingredient in the Wheat may be causing the problem?

You're talking about people with a real health problem. They discover that avoiding gluten seems to help. In practical terms, to avoid the health problem they need to communicate to others what is, as best as they can tell, they need to avoid.

They can't magically click their fingers and know exactly what the problem is. It takes research like this to find out stuff like that. In the time being people have to get on with their lives. Now there's an opportunity for them to know better, an opportunity that didn't exist before.

It's like you're expecting people to somehow have known in advance exactly what was going on.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by basch on Wednesday March 22, 2017 @05:19PM (#13935086)
>They discover that avoiding gluten

no thats not what they discover, they discover foods that lack something, that sometimes correlates with foods lacking gluten ...

how many people eat pure gluten, by itself, as a control. no they eat complex foods that have many molecules in them.

I am saying, semantically, calling "wheat free" "gluten free" when its something else in the wheat, is to misidentify the problem.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by jamesrcole on Thursday March 23, 2017 @06:56AM (#13938714)
> I am saying, semantically, calling "wheat free" "gluten free" when its something else in the wheat, is to misidentify the problem.

I never claimed that gluten was the problem, or that it was somehow accurate to call gluten the problem if it wasn't gluten!

I was responding to your claim that the issue was likely FODMAPs, and I gave two responses to that 1) the people you claim likely had improvements by inadvertently following a low FODMAP diet would likely have been consuming a high FODMAP diet 2) there was more recent research showing that there was an alternative explanation for the FODMAP one.

Also, as far as I can tell, they don't know that it is something other than gluten. They don't know what it is.

> no thats not what they discover, they discover foods that lack something, that sometimes correlates with foods lacking gluten ...

What I said was correct. If they avoid gluten they get improvements. That does not mean that gluten was the problem.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by basch on Thursday March 30, 2017 @02:13PM (#13997605)
I wasnt the person that made that claim. I was answering where the "source was" aka the article you are replying to

your inadvertantly thing doesnt make sense.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by redpillamerica on Saturday March 18, 2017 @09:00AM (#13901061)
Ditto. I had stomach issues my entire life, diagnosed with "IBS", and tried a variety of solutions, from prescribed drugs to exercise to removing dairy from my diet. None of these had any discernible effect on my symptoms. Finally in my mid 30s, at my wits end, I tried a gluten-free diet. Now 7 years later, my symptoms are 80-90% improved. And, note, whenever I reintroduce gluten into my diet, my previous symptoms return.
Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by mrfusion on Saturday March 18, 2017 @08:35AM (#13901011)
Have you tried organic vs non organic gluten containing products?

I e always been curious if cases like yours are herbicide pesticide related.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by ptaipale on Saturday March 18, 2017 @09:04AM (#13901077)
Just for the note, "organic" does not mean "herbicide and pesticide free". It means "using only herbicides and pesticides approved by the governing body".

Frequently quoted in HN:

https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/science-sushi/httpblogs...

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by mrfusion on Saturday March 18, 2017 @11:32AM (#13901678)
You're right. I should have clarified I'm most concerned about roundup.
Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by ptaipale on Saturday March 18, 2017 @03:26PM (#13903037)
It might be worth testing what makes one feel better. But you should do it with a blind study, to avoid bias and placebo effect.

It could indeed be that Roundup causes prolbems , although rationally thinking, the pesticides used in organic farming could be a more likely reason - e.g. copper is far more toxic to mammals (LD50 30 mg/kg) than Roundup (5600 mg/kg, safer by a factor of 100), and the amounts used in organic farming can be higher then those used with Roundup in conventional farming.

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by petercooper on Saturday March 18, 2017 @08:50AM (#13901041)
I haven't. I'd give it a go but I'd need to have a week where I wasn't going far afield(!) :) I eat gluten-free food which isn't marked as organic and have no problems with that so far.

I do acknowledge my reactions might not be gluten per se and could be more subtle. However, my father does have biopsy-confirmed celiac disease, so I'm wondering if I've "caught it early" - GI trouble is the main malady across my father's family so if restricting my diet keeps me away from that, I'll pay that price as I've never been a foodie anyway :-)

Re:Scientists Who Found Gluten Sensitivity Evidence Failed t... by mrfusion on Saturday March 18, 2017 @09:01AM (#13901066)
Very interesting. A blind test would be interesting too. Eat gluten and gluten free versions of the same food without knowing which is which.