News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by tptacek on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:46PM (#13897338)
Since I never said anything about doctors being monsters, I don't accept the premise of the question.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by steven777400 on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:30PM (#13897711)
Sorry for being unclear. You said: "Nobody bats an eyelash when doctors refuse to help with executions". So I just wanted to flip it around; if the doctor willingly agrees to assist in an execution, what, if any, implications or judgments does that entail?
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by squadAutomatic on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:19PM (#13898484)
Does that require clarification? Is this some kind of socratic dissection? Are we going to take this somewhere, after we get the obvious part in writing?

When a doctor assists in an execution, they participate in what is a murder, just under some other context. Lift that action up and out of the auspices of state and governance, and you have a murderer, accessory to before or after, or an accomplice to.

This isn't a particularly rare occurrence, but someone is there to cut the life short, do harm, and achieve a goal. Justice, revenge, passion, grudges aside. There's a winner and a loser.

It could be a misanthrope and henchmen, or it could be a doctor, somehow more distinguished than a common thug. The doctor chooses gets hands dirty for different reasons, there they are all the same. But the doctor gets to walk away from his murder, and commit more, so long as the state and government are not deposed.