News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google won’t be able to resist listening in on your conve... by Navarr on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:43PM (#13896129)
Yes, I did. My thoughts were based off the original article, which is what I quoted the follow up statement from.

What's the difference between "advertisement" and unpaid product promotion the user is likely to be highly interested in knowing has been released?

Re:Google won’t be able to resist listening in on your conve... by raesene9 on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:13PM (#13897030)
if a company is telling me about their products which I would have to pay to consume (e.g a movie), and I didn't specifically ask to be told about the (by active consent), that's an advert.

Also really not sure why you don't think Disney paid for this, Google's wording was ambiguous on that topic at best and the idea they're doing this out of the goodness of their hearts stretches belief more than a little.

Re:Google won’t be able to resist listening in on your conve... by Navarr on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:51PM (#13897378)
Beauty and the Beast is not a Google product (unless you stretch some definitions - I imagine Google probably owns some small stake in Disney right? would be a good investment).

Google knows I like Pokémon - just from my search results - would telling me the new Pokémon games are out be an advertisement?

Where do we draw the line?

I'm of the opinion, that based on Google's wording, they were not paid for this placement - which is why they'd be refusing to call it an advertisement.

Re:Google won’t be able to resist listening in on your conve... by raesene9 on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:33PM (#13897733)
Of course it's not, it's a Disney product, an advertiser who uses Google's platform to advertise. Just like when you use Google's search you get adverts for other people's products at the top.

Google are not generally known for providing free promotional content for other large commercial companies, so whilst you can choose to believe that it was unpaid that, combined with the fact that both news articles referenced and users whe received it referred to it as an advert, would suggest to me that on the balance of probabilities, you are incorrect.