Re:HTTPS Interception Weakens TLS Security
by icebraining on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:40AM
(#13894801)
Frankly, regarding MITM, that paper is just nonsense. How can it "ensure contents of a message are secure on the 'wire', by encrypting with a secondary scheme between the JavaScript client and the server", when you can't even guarantee that the signing and encryption code isn't tampered with in-flight?
And you can't guarantee that you can notify either, and for the same reason. The code that leaves your server won't be the code that actually runs on the client - it'll be a mutated version that will say "everything is OK" and acts normally to your server while it sends all the data somewhere else.
Nothing has changed since [1] was written; I don't see how that is anything but DRM promising more than it can deliver.
And you can't guarantee that you can notify either, and for the same reason. The code that leaves your server won't be the code that actually runs on the client - it'll be a mutated version that will say "everything is OK" and acts normally to your server while it sends all the data somewhere else.
Nothing has changed since [1] was written; I don't see how that is anything but DRM promising more than it can deliver.
[1] https://www.nccgroup.trust/us/about-us/newsroom-and-events/b...