The only time you are allowed to work unpaid overtime is if your job is considered an 'exempt' position. There are a number of rules that have to be met for a job to be considered expempt, including a high enough salary, autonomy over your work, and a few other rules as well.
When I was ready to leave, I filed a Department of Labor complaint and got a few thousand bucks.
They expected us to show up 10-15 minutes before the start of our shift to open and if we were on the later shift, they expected us to work 10-15 minutes after the end of the shift to close.
I refused to work for free.
I have never regretted losing that job.
Not worth your time, nor return on time invested.
Labor boards don't give a "stern talking to," they investigate violations of the law, issue fines, and even force companies to pay back wages, with interest, and other forms of compensation directly to employees. I just did a Google and this first thing that came up "Walt Disney Co. has agreed to provide $3.8 million in back wages to thousands of hotel- and timeshare-resort workers after the U.S. Labor Department investigated violations of minimum wage, overtime and record keeping rules."
I once reported a bank to the CPFB (not a labor board but similar) and it took 10 minutes to fill out an online form and they took care of investigating the issue for me. Ended up getting the $500 I was owed as well as an apology.
My co-workers might have gotten more out of it but since I got fired and they didn't, they should have been the ones to call.
These labor boards tend to be pretty vocal about defending the rights of employees. However, employees don't always know to invoke their help, and they don't have unlimited resources.
A company not paying wages for time that employees have worked is a pretty open-and-shut case for them to handle.
The worst part is it was probably just some shitty manager making 35k a year looking for a good year end review or a tiny bonus.
There is no way the corporate policy was unpaid overtime.
It's just as bad as taking money out of an employee's paycheck, and way more corrosive to society than petty theft.
edit concrete example: Blockbuster Video. Shop closed at 11, the time I stopped getting paid. At that point I had to lock up and do accounts stuff, clean, and general admin (plugging the CC machine into the phone line so it could phone home and get lists of updated cards to watch for) etc. Would usually take about half an hour ISTR.