Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by mwane on Thursday March 16, 2017 @01:55PM
(#13887222)
Which means there is no real difference; if all the types are known, it's just some form of Hungarian notation?
Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by Smaug123 on Thursday March 16, 2017 @05:48PM
(#13889520)
No, you can't do this. The Wikipedia page [1] contains a simple example which hopefully makes things clearer.
Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by mwane on Thursday March 16, 2017 @09:58PM
(#13890760)
Well, is f really a function of x and y when only one of them can be chosen? Seems like an abuse of notation that introduces unnecessary special cases. Abstractions (here: a function) should be simple and well-defined, not overloaded by natural language.
Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by Smaug123 on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:56AM
(#13892096)
Strictly, if one knows in advance that y is a function of x, then one should write f(x, y(x)) to make the dependency clear. This just gets unwieldy, though, as anyone who's ever programmed in Mathematica can tell you. However, what if a priori we only know that f is a function of two variables, and then we decide to evaluate it along a path {(x, y(x)): x in reals}? Under your scheme, we'd have to define a new function g(x) = f(x, y(x)) and reason only about g, which is even more painful, not least because maybe g(x) only depends on x through y and could be written more succinctly as g(y(x)).
The current notation is simply more flexible and easier to use, and it remains unambiguous because we have access to these two operators $\dfrac{\partial}{\partial x}$ and $\dfrac{d}{dx}$.
Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by piefoot on Thursday March 16, 2017 @03:35PM
(#13888387)
if a function depends only on multiple variables then those are partial derivatives, if the function depends only on one variable then there is only one derivative d/dx
Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by mwane on Thursday March 16, 2017 @03:52PM
(#13888557)
I get that, but ultimately, why does the notation distinguish between the two classes "function with zero arguments held constant" and "function with n >= 1 arguments held constant"? It seems somewhat of an arbitrary distinction, when in fact the value of n is always clear from the context.
Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by piefoot on Thursday March 16, 2017 @05:23PM
(#13889336)
I think that the difference is from historical reasons, anyway when if you introduce in school partial derivatives with functions of only one variable that is confusing because here partial is not partial but global.
Re:University of Tokyo Graduate School Entrance Exam – Mathe...
by sidusknight on Thursday March 16, 2017 @03:56PM
(#13888585)
I think his point is that you can always use the partial derivative notation and be correct.
"del F/del y = d/dx(del F/del y')" is just the Euler-Lagrange equation.