Re:Information Avoidance: How People Select Their Own Reality
by pjc50 on Thursday March 16, 2017 @08:13AM
(#13884352)
Yeah, a lot of this stuff isn't "intellectual" discussion in the sense of a dispassionate search for truth but instead a form of loyalty signalling. On reading it you ask yourself, "why would anyone think that?" and then go digging; several iterations later you find their entire set of experiences, beliefs, values and loyalties is different. And you wonder where it came from - but it takes a village to raise someone like this, and there's an entire community out there who think in the same way.
Epistemology matters, and can't be separated from power relations.
The person with the extremely bonkers views is engaging in radical epistemology: those are his facts, because he doesn't trust anyone else's. If you were to dig long enough perhaps you'd find the point in his childhood where he rejected either educational authority or his own experimentation in favour of this fantasy world in which he's the sole arbiter of knowledge.
Epistemology matters, and can't be separated from power relations.
The person with the extremely bonkers views is engaging in radical epistemology: those are his facts, because he doesn't trust anyone else's. If you were to dig long enough perhaps you'd find the point in his childhood where he rejected either educational authority or his own experimentation in favour of this fantasy world in which he's the sole arbiter of knowledge.