As an atheist I have had some interesting conversations with what I would characterize as "intense believers". I have friends who are Born Again Christians. I have endured intense verbal poundings of all kinds at their hands. I even had a case where one of them was yelling and screaming at me in the middle of a parking lot at midnight because I was going on a business trip to Amsterdam the next day and he felt I needed to kneel down and accept Jesus that very minute or I would surely go to hell and condemn my whole family just for setting foot on that city. Nice guy and all, but holy crap!
BTW, I have never done the opposite and tried to convince a believer to become an atheist.
When do you think someone is so far gone that an attempt to engage based on reason is futile?
They "develop and take root" in a distrust of the established truths, which finds an outlet in some niche pet-theory (flat earth, etc) -- and an existential distress and unhapiness in living with them.
Which is not totally unhealthy, as a lot of established truths are either dictums or states of being held by force taken as inevitable/the way things are/gospel, and others are BS spread for profit (and also held as truth).
Of course rejecting those instead of the shape-of-the-earth type beliefs would be better. But it would also be more difficult (try rejecting an established "truth" and see how well it goes. In a repressive government it can even end in execution). Whereas believing in flat-earth at best makes other perceive you as cooky.