News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by seiji on Friday May 28, 2010 @03:16PM (#1387370)
It's their narrative for getting attention. That is all.

Someone once mentioned how it was clever they (tiny, unknown little company) always pit themselves against well known things (Microsoft, Apple, VC X) to try and become more legitimate over time.

Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by axod on Friday May 28, 2010 @03:25PM (#1387389)
They also claim that they don't want to grow. That every business has a 'natural' size. That somehow that's better than being massive - again challenging the conventional wisdom that more profit = better. They are masters of PR to geeks. Their business model pretty much relies on them doing constant PR to pit themselves as the hip small but hugely knowledgeable 'startup'.

Even the back cover of Rework reads like a parody of 37signals other stuff.

Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by JanezStupar on Friday May 28, 2010 @04:18PM (#1387521)
Why is that a problem?

Handful of guys doing what they like. Earning enough to pay for a modest lifestyle and I bet they get to put something away for old age.

Why does earning a living have to be an unpleasant and stressful experience?

By writing and talking about how awesome cool their careers are, they get to boost their sales. Hell, I think I might start writing about how awesome my life is.

Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by axod on Friday May 28, 2010 @05:34PM (#1387731)
There's absolutely nothing wrong with it at all. There are millions of small businesses doing exactly that. There always have been. Most of them just quietly get on with it and make profit.

For me, 37signals don't say anything new or very interesting. They just say it really loudly, and try to make out that they're doing something radically different - when in fact they're not.

Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by InclinedPlane on Friday May 28, 2010 @05:48PM (#1387761)
Yes, but...

37signals is not doing anything new. Tons of small-businesses have been operating on the same principles for eons. However, there is so much hype and misinformation in the e-business arena that this sort of otherwise brain-dead obvious business advice is in the minority, and stands out all the more. There isn't one single way for businesses to find success, online or off, but if web entrepreneurs followed 37signals advice more often than they do today they would probably be better off. For that reason I think they're loudness if fully justified.

Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by axod on Friday May 28, 2010 @06:21PM (#1387834)
I don't think that's actually true though. Sure, maybe if you only hang out in SF and don't know anything about business and just believe what you hear about startups, then you might have issues.

It's better to just think about it for a while, read a lot of different success stories, advice, etc and come to your own conclusions. But come on. Business isn't rocket science. You make something useful, work out a monetization strategy, and grow from there. That's easy enough for my kids to understand.

The disservice 37signals does is that they firstly only believe that a certain business model is viable (eg selling stuff directly), and secondly they suggest that it's simple for the reader to emulate 37signals, when they know full well that to do that the reader would need to create ruby on rails, build up a big readership/following, etc etc.

Any extremist view is dangerous when taken literally and in isolation.

Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by jbarham on Friday May 28, 2010 @04:43PM (#1387608)
Unless your definition of a "modest lifestyle" includes driving a Lamborghini (http://www.google.com/search?q=dhh+lamborghini), I'd say 37signals is doing very well financially. And that's probably because they're intentionally staying small, not in spite of it.
Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by axod on Friday May 28, 2010 @06:25PM (#1387848)
They could probably just shut down making web products and live off the life coaching business.
Re:Why is 37Signals always the counter-example? by alexyim on Friday May 28, 2010 @04:11PM (#1387504)
That, and the fact that they don't want to dilute what they say by considering too many viewpoints. They expect you as readers to do that.