News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by coreyp_1 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:11PM (#13871950)
I would love to play it, but I can't find a Nintendo Switch. That is, I absolutely refuse to reward scalper behavior (which Nintendo encourages via their artificial shortages).
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by merlincorey on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:17PM (#13871993)
It's available on the Wii-U as well.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by coreyp_1 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:21PM (#13872015)
True, but I don't own a Wii-U, and the Wii-U is 5-year old technology, whose production has officially ended as of January (http://kotaku.com/wii-u-production-has-officially-ended-for-...).

Scalpers are lowlifes, IMO.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by slantyyz on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @01:05AM (#13873939)
You could buy the Wii U version to run it on CEMU in true 1080p (provided you have good hardware)?

I hadn't been following CEMU's progress, but it looks like it has come a long way in the past year.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8Au_XrDKQ0

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by kalleboo on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:53PM (#13873179)
So get a used one for cheap from goodwill/eBay? That's my plan at least.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by Jaruzel on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:02AM (#13874329)
Once the sellers twigged that the new Zelda was also available for the Wii-U they've all bumped their prices up on eBay.

Also, most of the Wii-Us on eBay don't have the screen controller, making them useless (you can't set up a Wii-U without the screen controller).

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by 6502nerdface on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:37PM (#13872137)
> Scalpers are lowlifes, IMO.

If the two alternatives are a world where no new Switches are available for anyone to buy, and a world where some new Switches are available for a high price, then surely the latter is strictly better than the former. Your sentiment places the scalpers in an unfair position of "ethical entanglement": if you try to make a problem slightly better, then by not fixing it entirely you are now to blame. Other examples at http://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethi...

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by learc83 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:56PM (#13872282)
>If the two alternatives are a world where no new Switches are available for anyone to buy, and a world where some new Switches are available for a high price

And if that high price is too high for you to afford, then you are strictly worse off in a world with scalpers.

>if you try to make a problem slightly better, then by not fixing it entirely you are now to blame.

Explain how scalpers are trying to make the problem slightly better. I understand that you may think that they are making the problem slightly better for certain subset of people, but that most certainly isn't their goal.

Scalpers are trying to make money, that is their only motive. The end result is to allow people with a surplus of money to acquire items, at the expense of people who have a surplus of time.

Since people who have a surplus of money tend towards the poorer end of the spectrum, overall scalpers benefit the comparatively wealthy at the expense of the poor.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by vkou on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:55PM (#13872267)
Scalpers don't 'partially fix the problem'. They don't create new Switches.

They have two effects.

1. They change the distribution of a good from a lottery, to a 'whomever pays more gets it' auction.

2. Depending on how they acquire the good, they may or may not have a positive impact on the original vendor.

Because of #1, depending on your personal values, you can make a very compelling argument that lottery-based distribution of scarce goods is fair, and that turning it into an auction-based distribution (While pocketing the difference) is immoral.

#2 is applicable for things like concert tickets (Where scalpers take on risk, and provide guaranteed, but bounded revenue for the artists/venue), but is probably less applicable for video games/devices (Where unsold scalper inventory will likely be returned for a refund - at no risk to the scalper.)

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by 6502nerdface on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:16PM (#13872427)
> 1. They change the distribution of a good from a lottery, to a 'whomever pays more gets it' auction.

The original distribution was hardly a lottery, it was a competition on latency (i.e. competition to be first in line). They change the distribution of some of the supply from a competition on latency to a competition on price. Consumers vary in their ability and preference to compete on latency, and in their valuation of the time/pleasure trade-off. Assuming a fixed supply of switches (in the short term), scalpers add value for those consumers whose preferences are such that they would in this instance prefer to compete on price rather than latency, and are willing to pay the going premium for not having to compete on latency. Without the scalpers, these consumers would have no option but to wait for new supply. There's really nothing unfair going on.

Side note, high frequency trading is kind of an interesting example of the converse situation, where inability to compete on price forces everyone to compete on latency. Because the exchange has a minimum "tick size" for changes in price (a penny or tenth of a penny, or whatever, depending on the exchange), there comes a point where it is no longer possible for buyers and sellers to compete with each other further on price, and so the only thing left to compete on is latency.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by vkou on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:42PM (#13872572)
First in line, lottery, whomever waits longest in line... In many value systems, these are all more 'democratic' or 'fair' methods of distribution, then 'person with the most money.'

It's one optimization function, but not necessarily the best one. Especially when the original vendor does not see a penny of the scalper windfall.

The same number of consumers have no option but to wait for new supply, with or without scalper involvement.

The only thing that changes is the demographic of those consumers.

HFT arguably reduces spreads, and carries entirely different costs. It's not really comparable.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by ianai on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:22PM (#13873085)
Nintendo's already sold 1.5 million units in its first week. The Xbox one sold 3 million in its first month. Arguably, Nintendo on purpose let out fewer units than it needed to supply demand. They seem to use shortages as a marketing ploy from past releases. So the interested gamer has these two factors going against him/her: 1. the supplier cuts supply to gin up free marketing and 2. scalpers making an already hard to find item even more difficult to find. I think that's double the 'unfair' and thus not cool, bro.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by tgb on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:50PM (#13872229)
How are scalpers trying to make the situation better? They don't increase the supply, as in your erroneous hypothetical.

There's an argument for scalpers, but it's more subtle. Companies want immediate sales and to be able to say they sold out. Scalpers let them do that by taking on some of the risks themselves. And it ostensibly allows people to make a time/money tradeoff between waiting in line or for later supplies versus paying more.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by 6502nerdface on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:29PM (#13872509)
> And it ostensibly allows people to make a time/money tradeoff between waiting in line or for later supplies versus paying more.

See my reply to vkou. This is exactly how scalpers make the situation better, by creating the availability of the choice to make a trade-off, where before there was no choice but to compete on latency or luck (which is fine for many consumers, but consumers vary in their ability to compete on latency and in their valuation of the trade-off).

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by vkou on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:10PM (#13872761)
Giving people 'choices' in how goods are distributed doesn't always make the situation better.

Consider rationing when there's a food shortage. We can either feed everyone (At reduced rations), or we can let some people pay more, to get more food, at the expense of letting others starve.

Isn't it great to give people the choice between destitution and starvation? (Or, in the case of the poor, between starvation, and starvation.)

There's a reason rationing is common in times of hunger.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by tkxxx7 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @08:34PM (#13872889)
Why consider this example, though, when a Switch, or a concert ticket or iPhone or whatever, is not necessary for survival?
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by vkou on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @12:15PM (#13877147)
Video games are obviously not life-saving food.

I was using this example to demonstrate that optimizing for [choice/wealth] does not always result in better outcomes. Just as the parent post posits that optimizing for first come-first serve does not always result in better outcomes.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by tgb on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @10:15PM (#13873261)
The analogy of that to your link is... tenuous at best. Your idea of helping people out is taking it from people willing to wait in line for it to people willing to pay for it. I don't view this as an atrocity like some would, but to even begin to question someone's ethical consistency based off that is suspect. It's clearly a trade-off and not actually a "small but positive change that gets demonized because it's incomplete". It gets demonized because some people don't think it's positive.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by vkou on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:57PM (#13872287)
Unlike concert tickets, if the Switch bombed, scalpers would probably return their devices for a full refund. So, in that sense, they aren't taking on any risk.

I understand why a concert venue would be happy to get guaranteed income from scalpers, but this does not hold for consumer devices.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by aanm1988 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:53PM (#13872247)
Without scalpers then a shortage means the switches are actually in the hands of gamers who got them for a reasonable price, without some shithead sticking themselves in the middle.

Currently it's a bunch of people who want to play, but aren't willing to be gouged by a bunch of fucking assholes.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by 6502nerdface on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:18PM (#13872442)
> Without scalpers then a shortage means the switches are actually in the hands of gamers who got them for a reasonable price[...]

A reasonable dollar price, but an unreasonable requirement of speed and/or luck.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by aanm1988 on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:50PM (#13873166)
But with scalpers you make the initial rush a much harder battle (you compete with scalpers now too) so more customers are losers at that stage, and then losers again if they have to be gouged by scalpers.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by kronin on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @06:44PM (#13872185)
I preordered one of the 2nd round of bundles from GameStop a week ago with guaranteed delivery by Easter. My shipment is showing up tomorrow.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by ianai on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @09:06PM (#13873033)
I'm annoyed by the scalpers/shortage thing, too. Nintendo does this knowingly and it's frustrating. Apple doesn't do this stuff. I got my iPhone SE by preorder and the preorder window was open wide. There was no "oh you weren't near a computer for the one hour window they were on sale so you're 100% out of luck".
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by covercash on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @04:28AM (#13874638)
Maybe Apple doesn't purposely do it, but if you wanted a Jet Black iPhone 7 Plus and weren't awake at 3am when pre-orders opened, you were not getting one before December.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by chaser7016 on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @01:01AM (#13873928)
I know even GameStop got into the scalping it seems... I just want to go to a store and buy it semi-impulsively. The guy at a GameStop said we have them in our warehouse and I can sell you one for $600.

Ok nope I'll wait and there's only one game to play and none schedule to come out for months minus re-hashes of Wii U games.

On a different note..I bought the Wii U for my niece and nephew and MARIO Chase alone is tons of fun; money well spent.

Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by FreedomToCreate on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @03:13AM (#13874362)
You mean its apart of a $600 bundle. You are getting items which add up to $600 so it not scalping in that sense.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by Pigo on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @08:57AM (#13875741)
You are forced to get items which add up to $600, when you only wanted part of the bundle. That feels like taking advantage of people. They did that to me when I went to buy the first xbox.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @09:02AM (#13875760)
If the things you want aren't worth the price, you don't buy it. no one is taking advantage of you; no one has a gun to your head.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by Pigo on Thursday March 16, 2017 @11:59AM (#13886092)
They were the only ones who still had them in stock, because of their deal. I was a sucker because I couldn't be bothered to wait, and a learned a valuable lesson.
Re:The new legend of Zelda is a toy box of delights by smackfu on Wednesday March 15, 2017 @08:13AM (#13875523)
Items whose list price add up to $600 but no one would actually buy at that price.