You can take this logic to its extremes and assume that if you had only one very wealthy person living in the US that providing services for that one person would be cheaper. That wouldn't be the case.
Then how about if there's 100 million people? 300? 600? Generally speaking having more people should increase the economic efficiency. If you have a tax base of 600 million people that's going to give you more resources to save your piggly-wiggly turtles than if you had 100 or 300.
I am all for legal immigration.
Your comment might be correctly phrased as "leaving the hairy question of illegal immigration aside..."
> "you're assuming that economic systems on the scale of nation-states are zero-sum."
I'm not assuming that at all. I'm simply making a statement that California taxpayer funds (and since money is fungible) and federal funds are used to fund people who live in this country illegally and that is only because the citizens of California elected politicians who are not fiscally responsible and seem to feel that it OK to use taxpayer funds to pay for people living here illegally.
As I originally stated, if Californians simply elected responsible politicians they would have the funds for paying for the electric train without the federal grant.
> Your comment might be correctly phrased as "leaving
> the hairy question of illegal immigration aside..."
No, it really couldn't. I'm replying to your economic fallacy of
asserting that "[a] program for a million people will cost more [than
a program for one person]". Of course that's literally true in terms
of absolute dollar amounts, but it's not true in the sense that
actually matters. I.e. if you had a million extra people in your
country would they be a net drain on your economy, or net
contributors?To answer that question it doesn't matter that they're illegal immigrants or legal immigrants. You can't assume that just because someone's illegal they're more likely to be a net drain on the economy, actually the reverse is probably likelier to be true, since an illegal immigrant will seek work but can't make use of social services provided to people legally in the country.
> I'm not assuming that [illegal immigrants are a
> net drain on the economy] at all.
I really hate to put words into someone's mouth, but the most generous
reading of what you're saying really does sound like that's what
you're actually saying.You're asserting that having X number of "illegal" immigrants is going to have some linear drain on the economy as a function of X, it's not at all clear that that relationship exists in any sense, i.e. it could be a gain not a drain, and it could be non-linear.
The correct term for the people is illegal aliens. No quote marks.
I support immigration. After all, my ancestors were immigrants. I do not support people living here illegally. There is the distinction.
I am generally support immigration. But we need to remain realistic.
Of course such competition exists. If an anti-poverty program for only me costs X, then that program for a million people will cost more [1]. It takes more resources, in aggregate, to maintain something for more people. That, in turn, means there are fewer resources for e.g. saving piggly-wiggly turtles or whatever. You could raise taxes, but that just means fewer resources in taxpayers' pockets in favour of more anti-poverty programs and piggly-wiggly turtles et cetera. Resources are finite, human wants are unlimited, and political capital is a delicate thing.
[1] citation needed