News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by projectramo on Monday March 13, 2017 @04:53PM (#13862246)
You know California is a net contributor to the federal government, right?

By your argument, California could easily afford to pay for it if only Mississippi, Louisiana, Tennessee, Montana, and Kentucky were not "mooching" off of it.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @04:57PM (#13862279)
> "By your argument, California could easily afford to pay for it if only Mississippi, Louisiana, Tennessee, Montana, and Kentucky were not "mooching" off of it."

Not if the funds are paying for people living in these states legally.. Surely you see the distinction between funding people legally living in the US and those living here illegally.

What I know is that if California elected responsible politicians that used tax money for Californians and not for people living in the state and country illegally they wouldn't need the federal money.

Get rid of your politicians and elect responsible ones and stop whining.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by entee on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:11PM (#13862427)
A major flaw in your argument is the implication that undocumented individuals in CA (or the US in general) do not pay for the services they use. While in certain cases that might be true, in others they are net contributors. See social security taxes [1].

I also think you're making a fairly inflammatory argument without providing much data or grappling with the practical implications of your argument. Even if we were to take all the money we spend as Californians on undocumented immigrants, would that actually come close to the funds we should be receiving for Caltrain electrification? I'm not sure. And what damage to our communities would be done by removing that money from the system? Immigrants, undocumented and fully documented, grow the larger economy and are meaningful parts of our community, and I'm pretty sure we'd be worse off without them.

https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/09/undocum...

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by masonic on Monday March 13, 2017 @06:33PM (#13863147)
The February study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy says that, on average, the nation’s estimated 11 million undocumented residents pay a total of about 8 percent of their incomes in state and local taxes each year[0].

That's total taxation, encompassing sales tax, and (for those not being paid "under the table"), income tax and FICA. Again, that's a national average; in CA, sales tax would make it higher). That's not remotely paying all of their own way overall.

As for overall impact: "Ira Mehlman of the Federation for American Immigration Reform said the $11.74 billion tax contribution covers only a small fraction of what undocumented residents and their dependents use in government services. The Washington, D.C. organization, which favors stricter immigration enforcement, estimates it collectively costs state and local governments about $84 billion a year to provide education, health care, public safety and other services to undocumented residents and their dependents."[0]

As for Social Security, they get that back as much as legal residents do, if they file for it. Quoting your source: "He calculates that undocumented immigrants paid $13 billion into the retirement trust fund that year, and only got about $1 billion in benefits." That's retirement benefits alone, being paid out already. As these payees age and retire, they'll collect far more than they paid in, and that will worsen as lifespans increase... hence it being referred to as a "Ponzi Scheme".

"We lose money on every transaction, but we make it up in volume!"

[0] SJ Mercury News, March 3, page B2, "Undocumented immigrants’ taxes calculated"

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @06:49PM (#13863258)
> "A major flaw in your argument is the implication that undocumented individuals in CA"

"undocumented individuals" is a euphemism that does not help the discussion and tends to minimize and obfuscate the language so as to seemingly minimize the fact that they are living in the country against the law. The correct term is illegal alien (look it up if you don't believe me).

My argument is a simple one that I think most people agree with which is this: people that live in this country illegally do not deserve taxpayer funds. I am not making any assumptions, just a statement.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by anoonmoose on Monday March 13, 2017 @07:27PM (#13863541)
I am not sure that most people would agree with you on that; at least, I personally do not agree that people who are in this country illegally do not deserve taxpayer funds. I think that's very similar to saying that someone who pays no taxes does not deserve taxpayer funds, which I also disagree with. Since most people who are living in this country illegally are paying one form of tax or another, the only difference between the two groups is the amount they've paid.
Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @10:36PM (#13864508)
Receiving taxpayer funded benefits such as K-12 education or health benefits has nothing to do with whether someone pays taxes or not when (think retired or disabled people for example) but rather whether they are living in the country legally or not.
Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:16PM (#13862488)
The amount of money spent for K-12 education people who live in California illegally as well as university education and healthcare far, far exceeds the < $800 million federal grant for the train.

> "I also think you're making a fairly inflammatory argument..."

I don't believe I'm an inflammatory argument. Fiscally responsible politicians would not spend tax money on people who are not legally in the country except on law enforcement.

The solution to the train and other fiscal problems is simply electing fiscally responsible politicians. The newspaper article mentioned the problem of federal funding and I mentioned a levitate and proper solution. If Californians don't elect politicians who are fiscally responsible and who feel that it is OK to spend taxpayer money on people living here illegally, they only have themselves to blame.

I don't see any argument that says that the Federal gov. (again because money is fungible) should be funding people who are living in the country illegally.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by entee on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:28PM (#13862604)
Bandying about terms like "living here illegally" and the tone of how you're putting it is very much inflammatory. Fiscally responsible politicians should carefully consider the larger questions and tradeoffs including costs of enforcements, larger contributions to the economy, and how much those immigrants actually pay in taxes. How about sales taxes?

Or approaching the question from the other direction, how about the larger benefits of the electrification project? By withholding money this way (and I'm pretty sure nobody responsible for the withholding has been making the same arguments you are, but happy to be shown otherwise), are we cutting off our nose to spite our face?

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:52PM (#13862798)
> "Bandying about terms like "living here illegally" and the tone of how you're putting it is very much inflammatory.

Well, they are people living here illegally. I don't see that as inflammatory but a statement of fact. How else would you say that?

> Fiscally responsible politicians should carefully consider the larger questions and tradeoffs including costs of enforcements, larger contributions to the economy, and how much those immigrants actually pay in taxes.

No, fiscally responsible politicians should not be using taxpayer funds to fund people who are living in the country illegally -- against the law except for law enforcement.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by TACIXAT on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:27PM (#13862598)
Do you realize that many Californians associate more strongly with the undocumented immigrants than they do with people from the south? That is California. That is the state they want to have. It won't be run the way you want it to. I grew up there. I would much rather have my money flow to my neighbor, someone who works hard and is essential to the economy, than someone in Mississippi, no matter their citizenship status.
Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @06:45PM (#13863230)
> "I would much rather have my money flow to my neighbor, someone who works hard and is essential to the economy, than someone in Mississippi, no matter their citizenship status."

You mean, no matter whether they are living in the country legally or not. Well, OK. But I see that there are a lot of veterans that have served their country throughout America and I believe they deserve our support over neighbors who are living in the country illegally. Let's agree to disagree on that one.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by gumby on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:01PM (#13862317)
Man, you really are upset with the idea of people living in California "illegally". Have you ever speeded and gotten away with it? Does that mean you also live in California "illegally" as that would make you also a scofflaw?
Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:12PM (#13862433)
I am upset about the whining. Suck it up California. You elected politicians who use your tax funds on people who are in the country illegally and then you whine because you aren't getting federal funds. Since money is fungible it simply means that you want federal funds to pay for people who live in the country illegally. If you really want funding for the rail which I agree should exist, simply elect politicians that are fiscally responsible. It really is that simple. If you're unwilling to do that, stop whining and suck it up.
Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by arjie on Monday March 13, 2017 @07:16PM (#13863464)
Haha. The moocher states can keep mooching and whining. Noblesse oblige. We will clothe you, keep you fed, and give you jobs. And you will complain and try to bite the hand that feeds.

But our kindness is indiscriminatory. Our hearts are big. And we're ever so strong. California will take care of even the lamest of the lambs.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by 8note on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @07:05AM (#13866482)
If you want to be fiscally responsible, that train clearly should not exist since it will be used by illegal aliens.

Instead, they should spend the money on giving their law enforcement tanks to keep at each existing station and then if an illegal alien gets on board, they can quickly destroy the tracks and/or train. That way, no money will be spent on aliens, period. Plus, the police get the armaments they need to defend against this immigrant threat.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by projectramo on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:08PM (#13862398)
I didn't downvote you.

I didn't make the argument that California should or should not fund anyone over anyone else. That is up to the (good) people of California.

You seemed to indicate the California could have chosen to spend its money in a different manner. You started off by pointing out "Money [is] fungible". I was just pointing out the logical conclusion of that argument.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:00PM (#13862307)
Instead of down voting, please state why you want to fund people who are living in the US illegally instead of funding a train for people who are here legally.
Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by Kluny on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:09PM (#13862403)
I don't think anyone wants to fund them, and we aren't. We pretty generally agree that they contribute more to the economy than they take out of it. The California agricultural economy would collapse without them since employers can't afford to pay legal wages.

Now, the fact that their business model is so unsound that they can't pay legal minimum wage is a whole other problem. But as it stands, California is getting a damn fine deal out of their illegal Mexicans.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by jimmywanger on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @01:50AM (#13865320)
> We pretty generally agree that they contribute more to the economy than they take out of it.

That fact is immaterial. The fact is that they're breaking the law, despite any other effects.

Would you be ok with somebody living in your back yard if they watered and weeded the garden? After all, they're contributing more to the property than they are taking out of it.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by Kluny on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @11:25AM (#13868240)
Well is material, since OP specifically said this:

> please state why you want to fund people who are living in the US illegally

Which I addressed. I also stated that the fact they're here illegally is another matter. This was the line in which I did that, in case you have trouble reading:

> Now, the fact that their business model is so unsound that they can't pay legal minimum wage is a whole other problem.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by jimmywanger on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @12:35PM (#13868994)
> please state why you want to fund people who are living in the US illegally

So your argument is that as long as each individual immigrant contributes to society, you're fine with aiding and abetting their breaking of the law? If somebody were a serial bank robber that donated most of their taking to charity, would that be acceptable also, since they're arguably performing a net service to society?

> Now, the fact that their business model is so unsound that they can't pay legal minimum wage

In case you have problems reading, the business model of their employer has no relation towards their legal/illegal status. I don't know why you'd highlight that particular quote of yours.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by eon1 on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:52PM (#13862796)
> Please resist commenting about being downvoted. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by davidf18 on Monday March 13, 2017 @06:52PM (#13863292)
People should have the courage to state their opinion instead of simply down voting. I did not state something that was incorrect at least as far as I know and if I did, I would like to know what is incorrect about it.

Perhaps there should be a rule that when downvoting, people state the reason. I suspect that some readers believe that people living here illegally deserve taxpayer funds. If so, they should have the courage of their convictions.

Re:A Silicon Valley Train Gets Stuck by johnduhart on Monday March 13, 2017 @05:02PM (#13862333)
I'm confused, where did the he/she state that?