Re:Lobsters and Crabs Feel Pain, Study Shows
by goodside on Thursday May 27, 2010 @11:56PM
(#1385653)
You don't need pain if you can't learn from it. If your environment is stable enough that you can operate entirely by innate reflex, there's no reason to waste genetic selection pressure on crafting sensations for the benefit of some passive, ineffectual observer inside the lobster. Or the observer itself, for that matter. Its almost certainly true that lobsters feel pain (response to analgesics is damn convincing), but it isn't obviously true without evidence like this study.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
> It may well be true that lobsters feel pain, but it isn't obviously true without evidence like this.
Then at best the evidence is inconclusive. This is usually an issue that is trotted out as 'fact' a lot when it comes to debates about boiling lobsters/crabs alive for food. So really the 'general knowledge' of this should be:
We don't know whether or not lobsters and crabs feel pain.
and not: We know for sure that crabs and lobsters don't feel pain,
because if they did, then I would feel bad about going
to Red Lobster for dinner.> response to analgesics is damn convincing
It's not. It just means you blocked the negative stimulus, so that innate reflex you mentioned does not trigger.
It doesn't necessarily mean they feel pain.
Personally I don't think this question is possible to answer, so I behave as if all animals feel pain and I avoid inflicting it, except when I have no alternative. And when I have no alternative I try to minimize the duration and/or severity (giving priority to minimizing duration over severity).