"get over it"? why?
Can I be the judge of what kind of UI controls I like instead of Apple deciding for me? This hasn't be a problem with any Windows or Linux app I've ever used or any webpage I've ever visited. I guess I don't confuse easily.
And without those same app store policies holding them back, how long do you think it will be before Android passes Apple's ecosystem?
200,000+ is a lot of apps, but how many of them are "fart apps" or something equally as useful?
The $4B in revenue also sounds like an impressive number, how much of that money is because users had to pay for apps to make up for the lack of flash? And why does it matter to me how much money they've made? Isn't that part of the problem? At the end of the day the app store doesn't exist to serve users, it exists to make Apple as much money as possible, this motivates them to maintain as much control over it as possible no matter what the cost to users or developers is.
Because Apple care about the consumer, not some techie with a blog. What matters to techies means nothing to the average consumer.
It sounds to me like the sensible choice is not to stick with a company that doesn't care about you, but to switch to one that does. Which is exactly what he did.
http://wellplacedpixels.com/ is a site that showcases the "UI consistency" among many iPhone apps.
Have you ever even bought an iPhone app? There's so much crap there with inconsistent UI.
1. crappy at&t service.
no argument here, except i've yet to find a cell provider that doesn't have crappy service (chicago), including sprint and verizon.
2. apple app store policies and requisite adobe/flash dig.
get over it. some people like consistent ui controls between apps (hello, HIG) for a less confusing user experience. and really folks, flash has never been allowed to be in the store, yet somehow they've built a 200,000+ app ecosystem worth > $4B in revenues.
3. I'd have to buy a new iPhone for 4.0
let's breeze past the android fragmentation topic. 3g, 3gs, and the to-be-name next version iphone are all capable of supporting 4.0. the author has a 3g.
Ultimately, my reason for switching can be summed up thusly: I used to feel that, to get the best smartphone software and hardware experience, I had to live in Apple's walled garden.
like the other points, this is highly subjective and up to each individual. in my opinion, having played with the droid, incredible, and hero, the best hardware/software experience is inside the apple garden.