News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The no excuses culture by kristianc on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:07PM (#13846663)
Ah the 'I'll fire your ass if you give me an excuse on the due date but of course an attempt to maintain an open line of communication between now and then will be met with sunshine and rainbows.'

Let's call this disingenuous bullshit what it is - management by fear. Don't tell me you're about 'collective problem solving' in an environment where people are constantly fearing for their jobs.

Re:The no excuses culture by cj on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:19PM (#13846716)
You missed Steve Blank's point.

My interpretation is he's simply advocating that if someone is aware of an issue that will set a project deadline back, don't keep it a secret and surprise everyone when the deadline isn't met.

Instead of "management by fear", build a culture where missing meeting deadlines is OK as long as a valid reason was communicated to the stake holders BEFORE the due date (no surprises). If a someone who's a project dependency had a family member pass away which will likely lead to a project delay, Blank is suggesting that's something that can be communicated honestly + transparently to a superior (and very much understandably - should be no fear involved). The upside is the superior can potentially reallocate resources to keep the project on track while not be getting caught off guard with a project unexpectedly derailed.

Re:The no excuses culture by rhizome on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:46PM (#13846842)
My interpretation is he's simply advocating that if someone is aware of an issue that will set a project deadline back, don't keep it a secret and surprise everyone when the deadline isn't met.

If this is his point, he's a lousy writer.

Re:The no excuses culture by jstandard on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:53PM (#13847724)
In reading the article I also had the same interpretation as cj.

Blank is talking about acknowledging and dealing with risks early.

Re:The no excuses culture by joepvd on Saturday March 11, 2017 @06:05PM (#13847789)
> Blank is talking about acknowledging and dealing with risks early.

True that. He also mentioned firing people for not complying with his new rules several times. And also that he did. Those seem like the more substantive acts of his reign, as communicated in this post.

Re:The no excuses culture by jstandard on Saturday March 11, 2017 @11:13PM (#13848904)
It does seem harsh and it's possible that some part of employee obligations are done from fear.

However, we don't know the exact circumstances behind the firings. I'm giving Steve the benefit of the doubt that he didn't fire folks who slipped deadlines just once, but removed though who consistently didn't deliver or acknowledge risks early.

Effective policies need teeth. Particularly if your company is in a lean position (emerging from bankruptcy). It reminds me of the "War time CEO" chapter from Ben Horowitz's "The Hard Thing about Hard Things".

Re:The no excuses culture by valuearb on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:31PM (#13847087)
He clearly stated this more than once.
Re:The no excuses culture by rhizome on Sunday March 12, 2017 @08:10PM (#13854142)
Then why rely on interpretation?
Re:The no excuses culture by davidgerard on Sunday March 12, 2017 @07:01PM (#13853754)
I suggest this message: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13846800 which sets out Steve Blank's behaviour in practice. He appears to work by making demands he doesn't understand.
Re:The no excuses culture by taurath on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:21PM (#13846728)
Further than that, the manager tells their employees "I've made myself too busy to ask you about what's important to me, so it's now 100% on you to do so."

That's like expecting your relationships to go well with no upkeep on your side, only a "tell me if I'm doing something wrong"!

Re:The no excuses culture by pm90 on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:19PM (#13846713)
Heh, I think it made sense upto the point where he threatened firing people. I agree that is too extreme: you're gonna quickly lose a lot of people who perform best when they're not under constant pressure.
Re:The no excuses culture by analog31 on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:03PM (#13847501)
It's not just losing the wrong people, but also retaining the wrong people: A common outcome of management by fear is that people learn survival tactics: Avoiding commitment, shifting responsibility, finishing tasks poorly rather than late, ass-covering, and outright cooking the books.
Re:The no excuses culture by btilly on Saturday March 11, 2017 @04:40PM (#13847408)
I disagree. Strongly.

A common attitude of effective managers as documented by First, Break All The Rules can be summed up by, "I never waited too long to make the right hire. I never fired the wrong one quickly enough." Having the wrong employee is very toxic for your organization and culture.

The rules that Steve laid out do not actually put pressure on people. They amount to, "Be accountable for what you say, try to make it work, and let people know quickly once you hit a roadblock." It is about effort and communication, not achieving results.

People who don't put in effort and don't communicate can't be made to, and can't stay. But people who do, can. And, on average, this will work out well.

Re:The no excuses culture by nercht12 on Saturday March 11, 2017 @08:32PM (#13848376)
>> The rules that Steve laid out do not actually put pressure on people. They amount to, "Be accountable for what you say, try to make it work, and let people know quickly once you hit a roadblock." It is about effort and communication, not achieving results.

Just want to clarify: It's subjective perspective. It is pressure and it is about achieving results, but it's not unreasonable or unexpected for any business. I pay you, you do work. Period. Or the company fails.

>> People who don't put in effort and don't communicate can't be made to, and can't stay.

Depends on the personality of the individual. Make sure you work with them first and figure out if you CAN get them to cooperate. If you don't bother trying but just put up the rules and say "follow this", there is the possibility you'll dump a good employee and have to spend the next 6 months getting HR to replace him/her.

Re:The no excuses culture by btilly on Saturday March 11, 2017 @10:37PM (#13848794)
Just want to clarify: It's subjective perspective.

Right. Whether there is pressure is a subjective judgement. But the fact that you feel pressure DOES NOT make it an objective fact that someone else is putting pressure on you.

To get to an objective fact, you would need to find fair and neutral third parties. Neither of the two people directly involved can actually judge.

As a neutral third party, my impression of Steve Blank is that he is probably a very good person to work for. I have been in environments similar to the one that he described. And I found them very good environments to be in.

Re:The no excuses culture by Asooka on Saturday March 11, 2017 @06:06PM (#13847799)
>The rules that Steve laid out do not actually put pressure on people

To paraphrase what someone else said, "If a person is saying you're pressuring them, it's not your place to say you aren't"

Re:The no excuses culture by btilly on Saturday March 11, 2017 @08:10PM (#13848285)
The correct form of that is that if someone says that they are under pressure, it's not your place that they aren't. However people both can be and are frequently dishonest with themselves about WHERE pressure is coming from.

The challenge with Steve's rules is that people have to fight defensive behavior within themselves. If you believe that Steve will use your actions against you, it is really hard to follow his rules. If everyone follows his rules with trust that things will work well, following them is easy and things work well. If you can't trust him, then you don't belong in that organization.

But given what I know about him from years of observation at a distance, he means what he says and says what he means. I do not believe that he will use people's actions against them. And it would quickly not work out for him if he did.

Re:The no excuses culture by rhizome on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:51PM (#13846871)
He comes from a culture where nobody is fired and failing upwards is almost a natural law.
Re:The no excuses culture by valuearb on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:33PM (#13847096)
If you aren't afraid of losing your job, you either work for the government or have a strong union.

For the rest of us, setting clear expectations produces the opposite of fear, it gives you confidence in what you are expected to do.