As a freelancer myself, I certainly don't think that business is inherently evil. I do, however, think that today's insistence on shareholder returns to the exclusion of all other principles (up to and including stewardship of long-term value) is hollowing us out from the inside. Find me a large American company who would ever do the kind of long-term thinking Deere exhibited in the 30's. There aren't any.
Charity is not at all what I'm talking about. Charity is good for what it's good for - but it can't keep a society afloat for the long term. Only a healthy business ecology can do that. Long-term prosperity is the only possible goal, and it can't be done with handouts or noblesse oblige.
I currently live in Puerto Rico. We have a lot of problems here - problems that are deep and long-lasting - but I think they can be solved with a business model that focuses on long-term stability even if short-term profit will be lower. And it will be.
I really need to write some kind of long-form coherent presentation of what I'm talking about in Puerto Rico, but frankly I'm still learning a lot of basic things about the economic situation here that have a direct bearing on how I see the future. So I'm not ready yet.
But thanks for your input! This is very useful.
Maybe that will help you do a long form write up on Puerto Rico.
Best.
Thanks for the link! MeFi FTW!
Walmart Puerto Rico is a wholly-owned subsidiary. Here, they've done less damage (there wasn't as much damage to be done) and they've done positive good.
There are 7 or 8 billion people globally and in my lifetime we went from being mostly agrarian to having more than half of all people living in cities. These are unprecedented global changes. We have nothing to compare them to.
And people keep bellyaching about overpopulation and global warming and THE SKY IS FALLING, meanwhile, people are living longer...etc.
I fundamentally don't agree with some of the assumptions behind accusations that Walmart is evil and predatory. That doesn't mean they are a white knight or have room for improvement, mind you.
Best.
http://redf.org
But I will suggest that you also reconsider your view that business is inherently evil or inherently prone to evil.
Historically, some of our most civilized civilizations, like Persia and Greece, revered the honey bee. The honey bee is a metaphor or mental model for trade. The bee benefits the flowers without harming them and it also benefits from the flowers.
Trade is a civilizing force. Yes, trade can be done badly and people can be exploited. But that isn't something inherent to trade per se. At its core, good business benefits both sides. That's why customers will pay you.
I am a woman and former homemaker and former bleeding heart idealist who used to do a lot of volunteer work. I have thought a lot about not for profit vs for profit organizations and I do not believe not for profits are inherently better. In fact, many of them require people to first be "losers" and also self identify that way in order to get assistance. This inherently tends to go bad places.
I have been homeless for over five years. I have seen how easily charity can go bad places. The longer I have been on the street, the more I have looked for market based solutions. The food at an eatery is better quality, thus healthier, than the food at a soup kitchen and there are government controls insisting on cleanliness, etc of the establishment. It is a vastly superior way to feed people.
I also would rather earn an income than seek charity. It is a better experience, it gives me more agency and it has a more positive impact on my life.
There are ways to do charity well and there are forms of charity that I am happy to receive and that I think are fundamentally healthy things. But a lot of charitable organizations strike me as a cancer upon society that the world would be better off without.
I will also suggest you read up on Deere. I wrote about it here, but should probably update it some time:
http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2014/04/lemon-mering...
The pertinent section says:
So here is a bit of history of some "PR" done right. According to the history section of the John Deere site: 1933 Business is almost at a standstill. Sales plunge to $8.7 million. Though it is losing money, the company decides to carry debtor farmers as long as necessary, greatly strengthening farmer loyalty.
As I understand it, John Deere was the only tractor company that made that choice during The Great Depression. Other companies repossessed the tractors when farmers could not pay. This really did them no good because there was no market for them. It really did not recoup them much, if anything, and it burned the farmers when life was at it's toughest.
The mild statement above about "strengthening farmer loyalty" does not give the same impression that I got from some article elsewhere. According to the article I read, for decades after The Great Depression, if you were a salesman for another tractor company and you saw a John Deere on the property, you might as well keep driving and not bother to stop and make a sales pitch because John Deere had that family's undying loyalty for generations to come.