You can have permission models for these things. I am not asking for untethered access to the entire machine without any permission.
I fully agree with this. The ideal model if Apple cared more, would be: fully sandboxed by default, the application can ask extra permissions.
But given that Apple does not do this, for me as a user 'sandboxed' is a better default for me than 'not sandboxed'. I can install/purchase the few applications that are absolutely impossible without sandboxing (e.g. VMWare) outside the App Store.
You can have permission models for these things. I am not asking for untethered access to the entire machine without any permission.
I would even be fine with both having to ask Apple for specific permission via the app submission process and then ask the user if it was ok to give access to specific things.
There are so many ways this could be solved both gracefully and effectively but because apple have decided not to use any real resources on the osx it doesn't happen.