1) I moved countries, now half my apps are on a separate account I have to log into separately randomly (sometimes updates need it, sometimes not...) and logging in and out of Apple IDs always confuses their system mightily.
2) Several of the apps left the app store...
So now if I see an app in the app store I'll look for it on the web to buy from the dev directly.
Even after re-purchasing an app that you already bought, it does not always show up in your purchases list. E.g., I bought Pixelmator before I moved. It won't show up in my purchases list. I have to purchase it again (for free) every time I install a Mac.
The next time, I will just try to keep a local bank account and will not migrate the account.
I did feel a little guilty that the dev was losing 30% but I did it anyway.
Now. With many apps I use shifting out of the App Store, it's a liability and I think twice before buying on the AppStore if I think I may be stuck on an older version after the developers shift to direct purchase.
The experience across multiple Macs and new Macs is too convenient to give up.
This and sandboxing. You can do sandboxing outside the App Store, but almost no developer does. I don't want most apps to have access to my complete filesystem.
If I am setting up a new computer, I have a shell script that installs all of the programs i commonly use, both CLI tools and GUI apps. The only caveat is that this won't work for Mac App Store apps. For that reason, I always get the non-mac app store app. I guess App Store is somewhat convenient, but IMO not as convenient as:
$ brew cask install 1password
or
$ ./install-all-my-stuff.sh
But contrary anecdata -- if I have a choice between a great app not in App Store and a just ok app in store, I buy from the Mac app store.
The experience across multiple Macs and new Macs is too convenient to give up.
I'd imagine this is even more true with a multi-Mac family with family purchasing enabled.
I will happily pay 2x for "don't make me think" features like one stop updates, purchase history and new machine restores, etc. Time is money, in the long run this convenience is cheaper.
OTOH, I buy a ludicrous number of apps so maybe my problems aren't typical.