Microsoft failed to get Visual Studio into the mobile app development world, simply because previously it only allowed developing for Windows Mobile which is, honestly, something nobody really cares about. With iPhone development support, they could get new markets for Visual Studio.
Apple wins because (I hope I won't offend anyone with that) Visual Studio is just simply vastly superior to XCode. It is a truly great IDE (as opposed to Adobe Flash) that could make OS X / iPhone development an awful lot easier.
Secondly, Apple doesn't make that much money off app store sales, they make by far the most money off of the hardware. This includes (though with decreasing relevance) mac hardware sales. This may not discourage all that many mac purchases, but will it really increase iPhone purchases? It isn't like Apple is having a hard time getting apps on the store as it is, they are already dominating in terms of volume. Not to mention, this would be reaching out to a world of developers that Apple has spent the last decade insulting as being incapable of producing quality products, exactly the kind of "crap" the "review" process and 3.3.1 are designed to "prevent".
The only argument in the back of my mind that strikes me as particularly persuasive is that Apple is gearing up way ahead of anyone's predicted schedule to simply stop making macs altogether, at which point they would need a solid alternative development platform.
Do you know this for a fact, or are you speculating? They don't break out app store sales in their 10-K, but consider quarterly hardware sales from Q4 2009:
- 3 million Macs
- 9 million iPhones
- 21 million iPods
In the same period, users downloaded 400 million apps, although it's unclear how many were paid. App sales are almost 100% profit, compared to the 20% net margins on hardware.Even under optimistic assumptions: 100% profit, average sale price of $5, 15% paid downloads, the numbers are not good:
400,000,000*0.15*5*0.3 = 90,000,000
That's nothing compared to the billions they are posting in profit each quarter.The hardware margins are also almost certainly much higher than 20%, probably over 30% on a lot of the higher end hardware.
At WWDC 2010, Jobs announced that Apple has paid out over $1 billion to app developers.
That means Apple has pocketed $428.6 million from their 30/70 revenue split.
A small amount of their total margins since the App Store was introduced in 2008.
It's something nobody cares about now, but back in 2007/2008 (when the last version of VS was released) it was a sensible choice. The iPhone was new and there was no app store yet, there were no android headsets yet, and the palm pre didn't exist. Granted, things have changed enormously since then, and that's yet another knock against Visual Studio's slow release schedule.
I don't see this as an improvement. It just reinforces that their approvals and rejections are completely arbitrary, based on whatever they feel helps their business model.
But yes, it would definitely help Apple and Microsoft. It's in both their interests to kill Android and set up a duopoly where we get the "choice" of which closed platform to use.
First it's a win-win for both sides.
Apple needs some positive publicity to help calm the ruckus over 3.3.1 changes, plus all the noise Adobe caused. They also would like to start calming any rumblings from the DOJ that are starting to tremble. This helps on all fronts.
Microsoft needs a positive win that says to the world, 'hey we are still relavent!', the mobile train might have left the station, but we're onboard!'. Also, this will certainly kick-up the VS2010 adoption rate, which will net MS a pretty penny too.
June 7th is right around the corner, so we'll know soon enough but this rings true to me.