News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by bambax on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:07AM (#13838629)
Totally agree. If you annoy the user too much, they will not try to circumvent your rules, they will leave and find something else to do with their time.

Also, the big question that's missing from the article is: who's the enemy? If the enemy are Russian genius hackers, then certainly very long passwords and maybe other measures are in order.

But the enemy is not always remote. I just bought a new iPad and had to reset my password and so-called "security questions".

In my experience, there are only two kinds of security questions: ones I don't know the answer to myself, and ones everyone around me knows the answer to (what was your first job, what was your surname when you were a child, etc.)

The problem is, in the case of the iPad, your enemy is not some James Bond villain in a cave in Ukraine, it's your 13 year old child who wants to use your account to buy apps, or your spouse during a nasty separation. And they both know, or can guess, answers to "security questions".

What I do personally is type random things as the answers, and write them down somewhere. But that doesn't improve security, it weakens it.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by dheera on Friday March 10, 2017 @02:49PM (#13841508)
It's also insecure to have password rules because people end up writing, printing, saving passwords in Google Docs, because they can't remember them anymore with those stupid rules.

Totally agree about the "security questions". They're just insecurity questions. Everyone knows what street I used to live on and what my previous phone numbers were.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by Raphmedia on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:10AM (#13838650)
I simply type passwords in the answers.

"What is your mother's maiden name?" - "gHk899iL@"

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by ryandrake on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:32AM (#13839802)
This is a good idea. Unfortunately if you have ever in the past (foolishly) answered these security questions honestly, you can't just now start answering them with your password, unless you keep track of which sites have your honest answers and which sites you just gave your password again.
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by wubbfindel on Friday March 10, 2017 @02:25PM (#13841282)
Don't use your password. Generate random passwords for each security question and record them in your password manager.

So-called "security questions" are the dumbest security measure.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by Macha on Friday March 10, 2017 @02:38PM (#13841416)
I would put a _different_ password rather than the same password. Lots of site store security question answers in plain text for csrs to verify etc.
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by delecti on Friday March 10, 2017 @02:11PM (#13841142)
That's a problem even if you answer honestly all the time. Does this website think my best friend's name is (example) Jake or Jacob?

My solution is just to keep those answers in the "extra notes" section of my password manager.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by Raphmedia on Friday March 10, 2017 @03:03PM (#13841609)
Did I answer "Ste-Citée" or "Ste-Citee" or "Sainte Citée" or "Sainte-Citee" or ... oh, too late, only had two chances to answer. My account is now locked.
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by GrinningFool on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:21AM (#13839220)
Annoyingly,some sites have started putting limits and validations on their security question answers...
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by syntheticnature on Friday March 10, 2017 @12:46PM (#13840449)
Ran into one where it demanded I choose from a drop-down list, e.g. "What was your first pet" had "dog", "cat", "hamster", "gerbil", etc. I recall the list having a scrollbar, but there was not even enough choices for eight bits worth of entropy.

Oh, and they referred to these security questions as "2FA."

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by gry on Friday March 10, 2017 @04:55PM (#13842510)
I ran across something similar on United.

https://www.united.com/ual/en/us/account/enroll/default

Derp.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by zeveb on Friday March 10, 2017 @03:35PM (#13841882)
And what if you never had a pet?

I love the ones that ask about one's favourite sports team (not everyone likes sports), or first girl (or boy) friend (not everyone has dated) or first car (not everyone has ever owned a car).

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by Raphmedia on Friday March 10, 2017 @03:55PM (#13842056)
I hated those questions as a kid because I had nothing to answer them with.
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by tromp on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:49AM (#13839919)
Imagine the site complaining that your answer has "too much entropy" to be correct...
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by pbhjpbhj on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:05AM (#13839078)
>What I do personally is type random things as the answers, and write them down somewhere. But that doesn't improve security, it weakens it. //

It weakens it to the extent of your physical security. But in practice how many crackers are breaking in to your flat [aka condo] to find your written down security responses, unless you're famous - or a target some other way (politician?) - in which case you should have sufficient physical security to protect the written answers.

Having security questions allows users to use hard passwords without the problem of losing an account. It increases the risk of personal attacks, for sure, but I'd warrant the chance of personal attack [ie by someone who knows you (or has gone through your bins)] is minimal for most people vs. the chance of an automated online attack.

I think it's right to minimise the online attack surface at the risk of the offline one for most users.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by bambax on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:44AM (#13839886)
If you're famous, answers to security questions can usually be found in the Wikipedia page about you, so you pretty much have to make them up.
Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by smartbit on Saturday March 11, 2017 @02:41AM (#13844673)
For security answers I let my password manager generate a Multi Word Phrase you can easily spell out in a phone conversation. Store those in my password manager under my account. Someone told me he had to go through a converstation with Apple Support spelling out 3 random 20+ characater passwords and it was a nightmare. I immediatly switched tactic.

Regretfully Apple has an annoying bug that the dialogboxes accepts 5-word phrases, but only remember the first 32characters, 3 words or something alike. Very stressfull when you’re trying to recover a password.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by ouid on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:22AM (#13839718)
I have never come across an authentication mechanism that actually required your security questions. There's always another route to restoring your password, which means that they do not serve a security function, but rather serve a convenience function, at the expense of security.

If you are willing to be brave about this then the best way of answering security questions is by typing a random string and NOT writing it down. You will never need that value again.

Re:Password Rules Are Bullshit by mjevans on Friday March 10, 2017 @04:50PM (#13842470)
I once did that for a site which I didn't want anyone to recover my password to and thus break the security. I -DID- write down the actual password.

Today, years later, I still can't login to the damn payroll site because there isn't a procedure for just completely resetting the password state of the account and it wouldn't let you log in without those extra things.

Since that point I have recorded every annoying split-password (that's what the 'security questions' actually are, a forced split in the single real password)...